Legal Issues About Trademarks and Domains
- Date: 2006-03-06 - Word Count: 526
Share This!
Trade marks are a name or symbol that are used to distinguish the goods of services of a particular company from others.
Similar to copyrights and other signs of intellectual property, the effects of the trademark system is territorial. This means, that each country has its own trademark system. A brand name like Machine Head may be owned by one person in the United Kingdom and by another, totally unrelated, person in the United States.
The domain name system, which is putting most of its emphasis on the .com title as the international domain, does not really jive well with the trade mark system because of the latter's fundamental definition of "ownership."
A case in point is the Prince vs Prince suit. Prince, the US-based manufacturers of sports goods, challenged the use of the www.prince.com domain name by a British computer consultancy company. The said company registered the domain in good faith and have been using it. The Prince sports goods company, which has no registered UK trademark, threatened to sue the British company for US trademark infringement. The latter counter-sued in the UK for the unwarranted threats regarding trademark infringement. They eventually won and the US company had to contend with just using the domain name www.princetennis.com.
Alternatively, a different scenario where the trademark owner will most likely prevail over a domain name holder's rights is in the case of Marks & Spencer vs One in a Million. This particular case was elevated to the English High Court in 1997 when various trademark holders, including the world-famous UK retailer Marks & Spencer, sued One In A Million, a company who accumulated a number of domain names under the well-known trademarks like Sainsburys, Virgin, Marks & Spencer, and Cellnet. These domain names, and others, were bought with the express goal of selling them again to the trademark owners. The High Court decided that One In A Million be required to relinquish their claim on the said domain names. This decision was further upheld by the Court of Appeal.
The One In A Million company's basis of argument was that domain name registrations were first come, first served", thus, the trademark owners do not have any rights to the domain names.
Based on the two actual court cases we can build up a clear picture about the interrelation of trademarks and domain names.
In general, domains that have no trademark significance can be acquired by the entity who registered them first. Continuous use of this non-trademarked name will allow the holder to build a reputation on the name. When the situation is between to legitimate companies who have a right to the name then, as with the stipulation of most laws in most countries, the first person who registers will get the domain. However, a registrant to a domain that is also a subject of a trademark and who does not have any entitlements is going to be forbidden based on the laws of most countries. For more information please visit http://www.auxesiaonline.co.uk
Peter Goldberg runs the website www.auxesiaonline.co.uk which is your expert resource for all business related issues.Peter Goldberg runs the website www.auxesiaonline.co.uk which is your expert resource for all business related issues.
Similar to copyrights and other signs of intellectual property, the effects of the trademark system is territorial. This means, that each country has its own trademark system. A brand name like Machine Head may be owned by one person in the United Kingdom and by another, totally unrelated, person in the United States.
The domain name system, which is putting most of its emphasis on the .com title as the international domain, does not really jive well with the trade mark system because of the latter's fundamental definition of "ownership."
A case in point is the Prince vs Prince suit. Prince, the US-based manufacturers of sports goods, challenged the use of the www.prince.com domain name by a British computer consultancy company. The said company registered the domain in good faith and have been using it. The Prince sports goods company, which has no registered UK trademark, threatened to sue the British company for US trademark infringement. The latter counter-sued in the UK for the unwarranted threats regarding trademark infringement. They eventually won and the US company had to contend with just using the domain name www.princetennis.com.
Alternatively, a different scenario where the trademark owner will most likely prevail over a domain name holder's rights is in the case of Marks & Spencer vs One in a Million. This particular case was elevated to the English High Court in 1997 when various trademark holders, including the world-famous UK retailer Marks & Spencer, sued One In A Million, a company who accumulated a number of domain names under the well-known trademarks like Sainsburys, Virgin, Marks & Spencer, and Cellnet. These domain names, and others, were bought with the express goal of selling them again to the trademark owners. The High Court decided that One In A Million be required to relinquish their claim on the said domain names. This decision was further upheld by the Court of Appeal.
The One In A Million company's basis of argument was that domain name registrations were first come, first served", thus, the trademark owners do not have any rights to the domain names.
Based on the two actual court cases we can build up a clear picture about the interrelation of trademarks and domain names.
In general, domains that have no trademark significance can be acquired by the entity who registered them first. Continuous use of this non-trademarked name will allow the holder to build a reputation on the name. When the situation is between to legitimate companies who have a right to the name then, as with the stipulation of most laws in most countries, the first person who registers will get the domain. However, a registrant to a domain that is also a subject of a trademark and who does not have any entitlements is going to be forbidden based on the laws of most countries. For more information please visit http://www.auxesiaonline.co.uk
Peter Goldberg runs the website www.auxesiaonline.co.uk which is your expert resource for all business related issues.Peter Goldberg runs the website www.auxesiaonline.co.uk which is your expert resource for all business related issues.
Related Tags: trademarks, domains, accounting
Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- Domain Name Buying -- Five Pointers To Consider Before Purchasing
I would like to discuss 5 main issues with you, that you have possibly questioned before buying your - Allure People With An Appealing Domain Name
Domain names are turning out to be an advantage for thousands of international financiers and big bu - Vital Internet Marketing Strategy In Relation To Buying A Domain Name
In the pursuit of generating traffic to their blog or websites, most online business owners take on - How To Make Money Online - By Blogging - How To Choose Your Site Name
This is simple and cheap, it can be free if you don't mind not being the owner of the URL (website a - Choose Domain Names Wisely
How to choose a domain name? This question arises when you plan to create a new blog or website. It - The Perks Of Playing Online Strategy Games
How do you like to spend your free time? Do you find yourself lying lazily on a cozy sofa or taking - Domain Name Forwarding And Masking Gets Rid The Bad One
Are you just plain fed up with your current domain name? The world of business is full of decision m - Ways Of Domain Name Parking That Earns You A Sweat Free Money
Have you ever heard the term domain name parking? You thought that only cars can be parked? Then you - Secrets Of Premium Domain Name Buying And Selling Exposed
Ever wondered how people pocket money earned from just selling premium domain names? It's unbelievab - What Uk Domain Names Can Do For Protection
Any United Kingdom organisation can get a good domain name set up. In some cases that name can be in
Most viewed articles in this category:
- How to keep Visitors on your Websites?
If your Website is looking very attractive its very good but only looking attractive is not sufficie - How To Choose The Correct Domain Name
So you have decided the time has come for your business to have an internet prescence. Lets face it, - International Domain Names with Internet Explorer 7
IDN stands for Internationalized Domain Name, also known as multilingual domain names. It allows you - How To Protect Your Identity When Doing Domain Name Registration
The Internet has brought many advantages; one of these is having your own domain name. With the grea - Pushing Domain Names
Pushing domain names is a quick, cost-effective way to move domain names around to new owners. The - Registering Effective Domain Name
If you are thinking about building a website, registering domain name is an important step. Register - Choosing A Good Domain Name
One would think that registering a domain is the first step when setting up your website. This is no - Seven frequently asked questions about choosing a domain name
One of the most common questions I'm asked by my clients is "What domain name should I use for - eu Domains - European Domains
European domains is expected to go quickly and anyone interested in such domain names needs to stay - Free Domain Names: What's the Catch?
My high school economics teacher used to say, "There is no such thing as a free lunch". He implied