Fairtrade: is it as Fair as it Sounds?
The term "Fairtrade" has been gaining steady acknowledgment since the 1940s - and justifiably so. After all, when consumers pay just a little more for products like organic coffee, bananas, chocolate and even clothes, farmers are guaranteed a fair price for their goods and labour. So, the fact that over 2,500 product lines in the UK now carry the Fairtrade mark - not to mention that Britain spent over £290 million on fair trade coffee, food, furniture and clothing last year (an increase of 46% on the previous year) - should seem like a good thing, right?
Not quite, as many people are now questioning the effectiveness of the fair-trade practice - or more specifically, whether the support of Fairtrade purchase can actually damage the progress of developing world farmers. Many are claiming that a focus on fair prices for poor farmers doesn't necessarily address issues of mechanisation and industrialisation - radical changes that might enable farmers in developing countries to break out of the poverty cycle. In other words, they believe Fairtrade just encourages Third World farmers to accept and settle for just a bit more than they were originally getting - which still leaves farmers at a level of dependence.
Steve Daley of the Worldwrite charity told the BBC: "How can a few extra pennies a day from Fairtrade be celebrated as an outstanding achievement?"
Daley cites a report from the Financial Times last September, which revealed that a group of fair trade coffee farmers in Peru were getting 10 soles (about US$3) for working a ten-and-a-half hour day, in comparison to the 8 soles (about US$2.40) they were getting prior to the Fairtrade agreement. While there is a difference, it's not significant, and Daley is thus concerned that the fair trade movement is being reshaped to increase farmers' wages by small amounts, rather than to transform poor communities through development.
Madsen Pirie from the Adam Smith Institute - another sceptic of the Fairtrade practice - shares Daley's concern, commenting to the BBC:
"[Fairtrade farmers] become dependent on us continuing to pay 'premium' prices for their goods, [making them] prisoners to our market."
This perspective therefore claims that while small-scale fair trade deals are beneficial to some degree, they aren't enough for Third World farmers to lift themselves out of poverty; they need bigger market developments to achieve that.
Others, however, argue otherwise. , howevEileen Maybin, a spokeswoman for the Fairtrade Foundation, said:
"Fairtrade focuses on ensuring that farmers in developing countries receive an agreed and stable price for the crops they grow, as well as an additional Fairtrade premium to invest in social projects or business development programmes. Typically, farmers' groups decide to use the premium on education, healthcare and clean water supplies, or the repair of roads and bridges, and to strengthen their businesses, improve the quality of their crop or convert to organic production."
She added that farmers and workers involved in Fairtrade always talk about how much they, their families and their communities benefit.
Justin Purser, the commodities manager for Trade Aid Importers in New Zealand, has also witnessed some of the big changes fair trade can make:
"It is very common for fair trade coffee co-operatives to seek to build infrastructure which will cut down on the amount of labour required to process their coffee, and will also enable them to improve their coffee quality and, thereby, the higher prices they can command in the market."
So, the debate of whether fair trade promotes dependency or self-sufficiency continues. However, one thing is certain: fair trade conditions are far more beneficial to Third World farmers than non-fair trade conditions. So, while bigger issues may still be at hand, Fairtrade is certainly a starting point to put an end to cheap production through exploitation. Moreover, buying Fairtrade is something everyone can personally do on a daily basis to help.
There are various ways to support the fair trade practice: you could always pick fair trade products when faced with a choice of fairtrade or non-fairtrade. Many stores, markets and coffee shops do, after all, stock products from both categories. However, why not shop specifically for fair trade products? Or better yet, if the store you normally shop at doesn't stock fair trade products, ask them if they plan to. If companies see enough consumer interest in the fair-trade practice, they may very well decide to switch over - and every little bit counts.
Related Tags: organic, coffee, fairtrade, fair trade, third world, shops, produce
Andrew Regan is a freelance online journalist.
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- Know The Basics Of International Business Gift Giving
Businessmen would agree that in the business world, giving gifts once in a while can never be avoide - Investigation Interview Technique: Surveys
Surveys are a great way to gather information during investigation witness interviews. Surveys save - Mitigating Fraud Through Company Hiring Practices
A quarter of the fraud cases included in the Association of Certified Fraud Examiners 2008 Report to - Preventing Sexual Harassment In The Workplace
Organizations are responsible for creating a safe work environment, free from sexual harassment. Sex - Cost Effective Internal Investigation Tools
Businesses cannot afford the costs associated with workplace theft, lawsuits and unproductive proces - Rent To Own Statutes Affecting Your Business
Although the judiciary, symbolized by a blindfolded woman holding a balance, is supposed to be impar - How To Balance Friends And Work
Friends and work can both be personally fulfilling. However the social networks and acquaintances th - The Pros And Cons Of Corruption
Corruption runs against the grain of meritocratic capitalism. It skews the level playing-field; it i - Ethical Lockpicking
Robert Campbell, a locksmith who owns Advantage Locksmith in New York City, answers some ethical que - Trend Watch: The Real Deal
DefinitionTransparency walks the divide between honesty and an unapologetic attitude in the search f
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Difference Between Online And Offline Stock Trading
The introduction of the Internet has surprisingly changed our way of life as a society. It has defin - Does Personality Matter When Running a Business?
In order to run a business you need to have the ability to handle one. You must have certain qualiti - Business Law - Ethic of the Business
Business Law Before you start a business, legally, you need to obtain any business licenses or perm - CEO Compensation And Pay - Are Millions Of Dollars Justifiable
Many workers and consumers distrust CEOs (in part due to recent scandals like at Enron) and believe - Credibility - Without It You're NOWHERE
Internet marketers, when making a list of the things they think they need in order to successfully r - Jest Practices: Best Practices for Humor in the Workplace
Most agree that humor in the workplace can have beneficial effects. Yet not all humor is good humor. - Ethics And Business-What About Civic Responsibility?
The question whether business and ethics are mutually inclusive remains to be one of the most contro - Balancing the Needs of Customers and Shareholders in a Public Corporation
Many people say; It is All About Money when it comes to big corporations. Well yes, that is their jo - The Dilemma of Nanotechnology - Science vs. Ethics
What is Nanotechnology and why should I care about it?Nanotechnology, referred to commonly as molecu - What Are You Selling?
This has been on my mind for sometime. You see, we all have dreams, we all need money, but how are w