How Massachusetts General Law 93A Affects Online Businesses
When evaluating a potential consumer protection claim, it is necessary to keep in mind that the required elements are different for a business and a consumer. A consumer must follow certain procedural and substantive requirements outlined in section 9 of the act. Among other elements, section 9 requires a 30 day demand letter, a showing that they are in fact a consumer, an unfair or deceptive practice, and a showing of damages.
Businesses, especially online businesses, differ substantially in their required elements. Section 11 sets out the requirements for a business 93A claim, and requires that a business show: That they are a "business" - [involved in the conduct of any trade or commerce];
That the defendant engaged in an "unfair method of competition" or the defendant's actions were "unfair" or "deceptive;"
That these actions occurred primarily and substantially within Massachusetts (the burden is on the defendant to disprove this presumption as a defense); and
That these actions resulted in a loss to the business plaintiff of money or property, real or personal, for money damages to issue; or
That these actions "may have the effect of causing such loss of money or property."
Mass. Gen. Law 93A Because of the openness of the internet, and the anonymity involved, it can be extremely difficult to demonstrate that a certain method was either unfair or deceptive. More difficult, especially in the context of an online business, is demonstrating that a certain act has the effect of causing damages or loss. Since online transactions vary in amount and since the market is continually expanding, it can be extremely difficult to demonstrate actual loss, or even potential for loss. Since each element must be present before filing a claim, the prudent advocate will research the facts of the case prior to initiating a 93A claim. Without the properly pled elements, most judges will discard with the case at the first possible opportunity.
In addition, online businesses present unique jurisdictional issues that may confuse the use of 93A for consumer protection purposes. In order for there to be any hope of applying 93A to an online business, the "unfair or deceptive act" must have primarily or substantially occurred within the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. When neither the deceptive/unfair act, nor the harm takes place in MA, a consumer protection claim will be barred based upon 93A, even if the victim is a Massachusetts resident or business. In the recent Massachusetts Superior Court case of Fillmore v. Leasecomm Corp., the judge dismissed a consumer protection claim brought by a Massachusetts company against a California company because the allegedly deceptive sales tactics and the unfair contracts were all consummated in California. Fillmore v. Leasecomm Corp., 18 Mass. L. Rptr. 560, 2004 WL 3091642 (Mass. Super. Ct. Nov. 15, 2004). In Fillmore, the plaintiff's pleadings failed the 'center of gravity' test applied for jurisdictional purposes, and the claim was therefore dismissed. When deciding whether or not to file a consumer protection claim in Massachusetts, it is best first to look at the act, the harm and the jurisdiction. The more that occurred within Massachusetts jurisdiction, the more likely the claim will be allowed to proceed. However, Massachusetts courts do find in favor of Massachusetts companies when all the elements, including the jurisdictional ones are met. If a contract was to be performed in Massachusetts, and the damages took place in Massachusetts, then the jurisdictional element will be met and the court will find for the claimant, as the Massachusetts appeals court did in Auto Shine Car Wash Sys. v. Nice 'n Clean Car Wash, Inc. In Auto Shine, the parties frequently met in Massachusetts, and the misrepresentation originated in Massachusetts. The court held in favor of the plaintiff for double damages, as there was a willful and knowing violation of Mass. Gen. Laws ch. 93A 58 Mass. App. Ct. 685 (Mass. Appeals Ct. 2003).
Filing a consumer protection claim presents a substantially increased level of evidence and jurisdiction requirements when your client is a business. Beware of the consequences and potential wasted time you may use when filing a claim without having every element met. Simply because Massachusetts provides for an express right for businesses to file claims, doe not mean that judges will be willing to overlook even the smallest discrepancies in the pleading requirements.
Related Tags: e-commerce, consumer protection, cyberlaw, 93a, civil litigation, cyber law, deceptive business
This article was written by Nicholas J. Deleault, Pierce Law Center '07. Nicholas writes select legal articles for the Law Firm of Goldstien and Clegg, a Massachusetts cyberlaw firm.
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- Law of Services---transfer of Employees
Law of services-----Transfer of employees. When we are in service, it is possible that - How to Find Texas District Court Records
Because everything is bigger in Texas doing a search for Texas district court records can be quite - Finding Oklahoma Court Records Online
Trying to find Oklahoma court records is easier then it used to be. Before internet records sites c - Law of Services--pay and Pay Fixation
Law of services-----Pay and pay fixation Every person who has been employed by an e - Law of Services----contribution Towards Gpf/cpf
Law of services------Contribution towards GPF/CPF Every employee must contrib - California Lemon Laws - Making Life Better!
We all are aware with the law and their benefits. Laws are made to protect us and provide us the co - Law of Services--annual Increments
law of services-----Annual increments? All the orga - Law of Services--assets and Properties
Law of services-----Assets and properties. Every employee must be hones - Finding Public Records Online in Missouri
If you live in the "Show Me State" and you want to do a background check on someone then you need t - Law of Services--an Employee Must Attain Efficiency
Law of services------An employee must attain efficiency. If you are e
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Common Questions Asked About Last Will Forms
WHAT IS A LAST WILL AND TESTAMENT? A Last Will and Testament controls the distribution of your prope - Pro Hac Vice Admission In Indiana and the Role of Local Counsel
You're an out-of-state lawyer with a client who needs to foreclose on property within Indiana. You' - Advance Directives and Do not Resuscitate Orders Explained
An advance directive outlines what wishes your doctor must follow if you become unable to make your - On The Ballet: Recent News At The Poll- Earning More For South Carolina State Retirees
South Carolina has consistently had one of the nation's lowest rates of return on its investment por - Ohio Worker's Compensation - A Summary
OHIO WORKER'S COMPENSATION INFORMATION Ohio Worker's Compensation laws provide a system of compensa - In Broad Daylight - Who Killed Ken McElroy?
The killing of Ken Rex McElroy could well be the hottest cold case on record. On the morning of Jul - Criminal Records Search
In due diligence research, a criminal records search is a typical component of the procedure. In thi - Supreme Court Role Law Or Justice? - 1965 Editorial
Should the U.S. Supreme Court be a place of justice, or of law?Though this question at first glance - Ohio Worker's Compensation - What is It?
Ohio Worker's Compensation - What Is It? Worker's Compensation is a system of no fault insurance cr - Connecticut Child Support
Connecticut child support laws are some what similar to other states in America. Most states have la