I Wonder Why Do Procurement Departments Still Exist Today?
It seems that some of the good old procurement and business bureaucrats have managed to keep this function alive and kicking while spending hard-earned company money trying to save it.
In fact some bureaucrats have gone much further and persuaded their boards to develop a sophisticated procurement system solution which they claim will save a huge amount of money.
They have even managed to convince their companies that after they build this great system, they will save even more money, perhaps up to 50 per cent, if they also use an e-procurement tool that will interact automatically with all concerned.
I am not saying that creating an IT system for purchasing is a bad thing or not needed to control stray spending and increase leverage. I am not saying that creating an e-procurement solution is not a good thing or that it doesn't save time and money, especially when buying paper clips and printer toners.
I am simply asking how much that saving is and at what expense is it achieved?
The overall success of any procurement department surely comes from its ability to increase the competitiveness of its organisation in the marketplace. This success largely comes from being a commercially-centred department facing outward rather than a system and process-driven one facing inward.
I think building the system and buying stationery using e-procurement tools should be left to finance to handle. They usually know best how to build and manage a computer system that deals with money.
When I worked at House of Fraser Group earlier in my career, a core function of the finance organisation was running the purchasing and invoice matching systems. The purchasing department or, as they call it in retail, the merchandise department, was more concerned with making deals, researching products and markets and managing a merchandise system to understand the movement of stock. The same department was resourced with highly professional expert buyers, negotiators and merchandisers.
In the indirect purchasing of goods and services, good old bureaucrats are still maintaining a function that has long been transferred to finance in the retail and manufacturing world.
Such bureaucrats seem afraid of facing the real world of negotiations, sophisticated markets, dealing with suppliers, markets and technology, creating relationships and, most importantly, handling change.
Professionals who really drive and contribute to the overall success and competitiveness of their companies in the marketplace are needed.
For once, I will not blame senior management or company boards who have actually done their best to create the right environment for the procurement department to flourish, modernise and increase its leverage.
Many companies have centralised the procurement function and made it part of the overall governance. All they got in return was more demands from their procurement directors to build new systems. Company Boards nowadays seem to hear one mantra from their procurement directors which goes something like this, "if you build it, the saving will come". But does the saving come?
You will never know unless you ask the right question - how much did your function contribute to the company's overall competitive position in its market place?
This is a commercial question to be asked by senior management and not a system and process based one. What does a 60 per cent discount really mean? It means nothing unless it is compared with other discounts given to other organisation by the same supplier in the same market. And not only that, but also, on what terms is the deal is based and for how long if this supplier happens to be strategic?
Procurement departments must move quickly before they are moved by someone else. They should become a commercially-centered function resourced with highly professional and commercially-oriented people who add value by increasing the competitiveness of their organisation in the marketplace.
At the same time they should relinquish their system administration responsibilities to the finance department. After all, the first task of computers when they were invented was to computerise finance.
Related Tags: negotiation, strategy, procurement
Osama El-Kadi is chief procurement officer at Centrica Plc http://www.elkadiconsulting.com
Born 1955 in Manchester England, Osama graduated in 1978 with a BSC in Economics followed by an MA in International Business from Alexandria University.
Osama El-Kadi's career spans 28 years within UK based blue chip corporate companies. Starting from a Computer Analyst Programmer at NCR, to Chief Architect for worldwide banking systems, to Sales Director for CAI Europe, to General Manager Technology at the House of Fraser Group (including Harrods), to managing group procurement functions for the Automobile Association (the AA) through to his most recent position as Chief Procurement Officer in the Centrica Plc group of companies.
Over the years Osama has developed and negotiated successfully;
Major initiatives for strategic IT cost savings, Multi million pound acquisition contracts, Joint ventures and partnership deals Lead the negotiations for the largest IT infrastructure outsourcing programme in Europe in 2006, Large scale business transformation and IT system integration contracts Large scale procurement systemsYour Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- North Minneapolis 2009 - "40/40/40 Community Benefits Agreement" Must be a Part of Business as Usual to Help Community Growth
"If it's not growing, it's going to die." ...Michael Eisner In 2009 north Minneapolis community
- Negotiation Probes
Your negotiating leverage is determined by how much you know about the other party's attitudes, pre
- Keep Negotiating Tactics Flexible
There is no right negotiating tactic if you have the wrong strategy or policy. Strategic objectiv
- Resist Like Water
The Chinese have a saying, "It is well to resist like water." When water is put under pressure or
- Negotiating Threats
Have you ever been threatened during a negotiation? You probably have received more negotiating thr
- Lyons & Wolivar, Inc. (l&w Investigations) to Teams Up With Smith & Brink at Iasiu Expo
WESTBOROUGH, MASSACHUSETTS...L&W Investigations, the foremost private investigations company specia
- Negotiating Starts With Assumptions
Most negotiations start with both sides having a set of assumptions regarding what the other side w
- How Do You Respond to a "take it or Leave It" Demand?
What do you do when the other party gives you a firm but polite "take-it-or-leave-it"? There are op
- Why You Should Have It In Writing
There is an old saying in the West that says that if the preacher talks too much about stealing, be
- How to Get a Fair Insurance Settlement
Natural disasters such as wildfires, hurricanes, tornados, and floods have been making headlines.
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Ecological Negotiation
Negotiation is a process of trying to arrive at a mutually agreeable conclusion about something. It
- How to Negotiate Like A Pro In Long-term Negotiations
Ever notice that negotiations usually go much better when there is a history of trust from previous
- The Art of Negotiation, Investing in ART, Investing in YOU, Its About the MONEY Honey! Part Two
Part Two:Ask questions, sheesh, never be afraid to ask questions.Don't be intimidated by people, the
- The Gender Blenders-How Successful Men and Women Mix-It-Up in Negotiation
Our early ancestors settled on a division of labor, dictated largely by biological necessity: The wo
- Let's Just Split it Down the Middle
Everybody's Used ItIn the realm of give and take it's almost genetic. On every continent, in every c
- The Art of Negotiation, Investing in ART, Investing in YOU, Its About the MONEY Honey! Part One
As an artist it is hard to not feel flattered when approached by a gallery. If you are a profession
- Effective Questioning in Negotiation
Effective questioning is a powerful and often underused skill in negotiation. Asking questions has m
- IT Contracts Negotiation-Who Lead-Legal or Commercial
While I have nothing against Lawyers leading any negotiation and believe they have a major role to p
- How To Structure A Negotiation
People who are successful negotiators, always have a well thought out strategy before entering into
- Aunt Cecile's Tremendous Negotiation Tip
My Aunt Cecile, rest her soul, shared a secret with me before heading off to the happy hunting groun