Was Columbus the First European to Discover the Americas?
- Date: 2007-08-15 - Word Count: 616
Share This!
The question of whether Europeans migrated to and inhabited the Americas prior to the modern discovery by Columbus has been of longstanding interest and controversy. In fact, for over 200 years scholars have asked whether late Pleistocene (18,000-13,000 years ago) or early to middle Holocene (12,000-5,000 years ago) Europeans also might have migrated to the Americas prior to Columbus' 1492 discovery. The question had been posed so often that by 1891 a volume entitled "America Not Discovered by Columbus," by Rasmus B. Anderson, contained a bibliography with over 350 entries on the topic. It listed claims of America's discovery not only by Europeans, but also by Chinese, Arabs, Welsh, Venetians, Portuguese, and Poles. However, the majority of the references supported the notion of Vikings as the first Old World cultural group to reach the Americas.
This hypothesis was confirmed in 1960 when Norse ruins at L'Anse aux Meadows on the northern tip of Newfoundland were found by Helge Ingstad. Evidence from L'Anse aux Meadows and a few other sites found on the north Atlantic coast indicates that Norse-related peoples settled a few outposts of a couple dozen individuals in North America around 1,000 years ago. These outposts did not, however, lead to a viable, unique population in the Americas. Instead, they most likely only lasted a season or two, based on radiocarbon dates obtained from the sites. Thus, if there was any contact with American Indians or First Nation peoples by Old World cultural groups, it would have been scant and short-term.
More recently, several sites and lines of evidence have been cited as supporting an even earlier possible migration of Europeans into the Americas. Originally proposed by Nels C. Nelson in 1936 and later supported by Frank Hibben, the Solutrean hypothesis has gained popularity in years as the Clovis-first model of the peopling of the Americas has been slowly debunked. The Solutrean hypothesis is based on leaf-shaped bifaces and the remains of extinct fauna recovered in the deepest culture-bearing stratum of several sites across the United States. Hibben noted that the flaking technology of the artifacts recovered from one of these sites - Sandia Cave in New Mexico - more closely resembled the Solutrean technology of Paleolithic era France than Clovis era fluted points from North America. The Solutrean hypothesis, as a result of this cursory evidence and the fact that the Clovis-first model is no longer feasible, postulates that Upper Palaeolithic peoples from Europe utilizing Solutrean lithic technology migrated into the Americas during the late Pleistocene (18,000-13,000 years ago), most likely along the partially frozen North Atlantic. Evidence supporting such an argument, however, has remained elusive and highly controversial. One of the most noteworthy limitations of the Solutrean hypothesis is the fact that primarily because the Solutrean ended in Europe at least 5,000 years before the first recognized lithic technology has been conclusively dated for the Americas.
Likewise, archaeological, craniomorphological, and genetic evidence argues against any pre-Columbus European contact or settlement of the Americas. In fact, there is a growing body of evidence and a number of sites that demonstrate long-term indigenous growth and cultural development in the Americas. Sites such as Gault and Cueva Quebrada in Texas, Monte Verde in Chile, Meadowcroft in Pennsylvania, and Cactus Hill in Virginia all point to a pre-Clovis initial settling of the Western Hemisphere. So did Europeans discover the Americas before Columbus? The evidence says yes. Did they migrate to, or settle, the Americas prior to Columbus' modern-day colonial discovery? The evidence says no. The only people who migrated to, and settled, the Americas before the modern European colonial period, based on the latest empirical evidence, were the ancestors of today's American Indian, Alaskan Native, and First Nation peoples.
This hypothesis was confirmed in 1960 when Norse ruins at L'Anse aux Meadows on the northern tip of Newfoundland were found by Helge Ingstad. Evidence from L'Anse aux Meadows and a few other sites found on the north Atlantic coast indicates that Norse-related peoples settled a few outposts of a couple dozen individuals in North America around 1,000 years ago. These outposts did not, however, lead to a viable, unique population in the Americas. Instead, they most likely only lasted a season or two, based on radiocarbon dates obtained from the sites. Thus, if there was any contact with American Indians or First Nation peoples by Old World cultural groups, it would have been scant and short-term.
More recently, several sites and lines of evidence have been cited as supporting an even earlier possible migration of Europeans into the Americas. Originally proposed by Nels C. Nelson in 1936 and later supported by Frank Hibben, the Solutrean hypothesis has gained popularity in years as the Clovis-first model of the peopling of the Americas has been slowly debunked. The Solutrean hypothesis is based on leaf-shaped bifaces and the remains of extinct fauna recovered in the deepest culture-bearing stratum of several sites across the United States. Hibben noted that the flaking technology of the artifacts recovered from one of these sites - Sandia Cave in New Mexico - more closely resembled the Solutrean technology of Paleolithic era France than Clovis era fluted points from North America. The Solutrean hypothesis, as a result of this cursory evidence and the fact that the Clovis-first model is no longer feasible, postulates that Upper Palaeolithic peoples from Europe utilizing Solutrean lithic technology migrated into the Americas during the late Pleistocene (18,000-13,000 years ago), most likely along the partially frozen North Atlantic. Evidence supporting such an argument, however, has remained elusive and highly controversial. One of the most noteworthy limitations of the Solutrean hypothesis is the fact that primarily because the Solutrean ended in Europe at least 5,000 years before the first recognized lithic technology has been conclusively dated for the Americas.
Likewise, archaeological, craniomorphological, and genetic evidence argues against any pre-Columbus European contact or settlement of the Americas. In fact, there is a growing body of evidence and a number of sites that demonstrate long-term indigenous growth and cultural development in the Americas. Sites such as Gault and Cueva Quebrada in Texas, Monte Verde in Chile, Meadowcroft in Pennsylvania, and Cactus Hill in Virginia all point to a pre-Clovis initial settling of the Western Hemisphere. So did Europeans discover the Americas before Columbus? The evidence says yes. Did they migrate to, or settle, the Americas prior to Columbus' modern-day colonial discovery? The evidence says no. The only people who migrated to, and settled, the Americas before the modern European colonial period, based on the latest empirical evidence, were the ancestors of today's American Indian, Alaskan Native, and First Nation peoples.
Related Tags: migration, archaeology, vikings, native americans, tribes, anthropology, american indians, indigenous, solutrean, pleistocene, first americans
I am Director of the Bauu Institute and Press, located in Boulder, Colorado. I am also the author of several books and articles, along with the Indigenous Issues Today blog. Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- How Hypnotherapy Can be Used on Children
Today Hypnosis can be termed as a branch of medicine which is quite unique, whereas in the past this - Confidence Workshops For Children
Every parent wants their children to be confident, happy, highly motivated and enthusiastic in order - Inspiring Children Using NLP
Neuro-Linguistic Programming (NLP) is one of the most successful therapies in psychology today. Init - Writing Term Papers
Students often tend to put off a written assignment, considering it to be a chore too formidable to - Naming In Term Paper
Give a descriptive name to each of your concept in the paper. Adhere using terms like "our approach" - Introduction Section of a Research Paper
Your introductions should not exceed more than two pages (typed, double spaced). See again the examp - Getting a Feedback of Your Term Paper is Important!
Get the feedback of your work! Finish your paper, having written it well in advance, so that you hav - The 1950's - Was Life Better?
Iconic TV shows like I Love Lucy, Dennis the Menace and My Three Sons seem to indicate that the 1950 - Online Classroom Systems Makes Home Schooling Even More Attractive
In the past it went without saying that you would send your kids to public schools. With public scho - 8 Helpful Tips For Surviving Military Basic Training
Getting through military basic training takes a lot perseverance. During this training it is best to
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Culinary Cooking Schools and What They Teach
Culinary cooking schools prepare you for a job in the culinary industry by providing you with the kn - How To Learn Spanish Quickly Without Moving To Spain
Learning Spanish is a popular pastime, as well as a serious goal for many individuals. Whether it's - How To Improve Your Life With An Accredited Online College Degree
With the information super highway raring full steam ahead, quality accredited online college degree - Online Bachelor Degree Programs Go Mainstream
The Internet has seen an explosion in online bachelor degree programs in the last five to ten years - Online Degree Program Just A Click Away
You want to go shopping, but your car is low on gas. You want to know your account balance, but do n - Online Paralegal Degree Will Open Doors
An online paralegal degree may offer the possibility of improving your chances in the legal professi - What West Point Military School Looks For In A Candidate
West Point is looking for well rounded young men and women who are good students, good athletes, and - The Importance of Effective Accounting Programs
In the past, small businesses like mom and pop stores were not required to maintain any sort of acco - California Schools Educators Retirement System And Lionstone Group Create Investment Fund
The California State Teachers' Retirement System (CSTRS) is the second largest public pension fund i - A Taste of China - Seattle Schools New Guest Teacher Shares Language and Culture of Her Native Hom
The Seattle schools have a new "guest" teacher. Zhu Dan arrived in the Seattle schools in January