A Basic And Simple Assessment For Bias In PsychometricTests: The 4/5 Rule
Psychometric tests should have been validated by a test publisher prior to being published. However, the test user should also pay due diligence and ensure that the test cannot be accused of having unjustifiable adverse impact for one group of people over another.
There is a simple guideline known as the four/fifths (4/5) rule.
Here we seek to ascertain the percentage of one group that is selected or passes through to the next round of a selection process based on test scores, compared to another group.
Let's say that we are comparing red people with green people so that we don't unwittingly offend anybody! If we find that more than 4/5 of reds to greens are reaching the mark, we have little to worry about.
On the other hand, if we discover that 4/5 or less of reds to greens are making it, we have cause for concern. In fact, in some parts of the world, we would be required by law to take action.
The next question of course is: If more reds are making the grade than greens, does this translate into work performance? That is, are red people better on the job than greens?
If so, the adverse impact is said to be justifiable because our test is accurately predicting differences in job performance.
If green people do just as well in terms of job performance as red people however, the adverse impact is unjustifiable. In this case, we must take immediate action and work with the test publisher to assess why the test is not accurately predicting job performance for both groups.
To calculate using the 4/5 rule is simple.
We ask: What percentage of group one are passing compared to group two? The groups can be red or green people (unlikely!), people of different cultural backgrounds, males and females and so on.
E.g., let's assume 80 red people and 50 green people make the grade:
So, take the lower number and divide it by the higher number: 50/80 = .625 - this is almost 63%. 4/5 is 80% and so our test would be said to be violating the 4/5 rule.
The next step as noted above would be to assess whether or not this difference translates into job performance. Then we can conclude whether our test is producing a justifiable or an unjustifiable adverse impact.
As always, the best advice is to start off with a thorough job analysis and to allow the choice of psychometric test to be informed by the job analysis.
Assuming the test has been chosen by a trained and competent professional and it is a reliable and valid assessment of the construct of interest, we are unlikely to encounter violations of the 4/5 rule. Even where violations may occur, if the test has been chosen based on this firm grounding, our process is highly defensible.
Related Tags: bias, psychometric tests, adverse impact, psychological assessment
Dr. Graham Tyler is a registered organizational psychologist and executive director of PsyAsia International, an HR training, consulting and assessment organization with offices in Hong Kong and Singapore, and clients globally.Visit PsyAsia at http://www.psyasia.com.
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- The Beginning of the Cataloging Code
The first significant cataloging code was published in 1841. The realization that cooperation and s - In the Lap of the Gods 24
Life moved on. Lily became well liked by both students and staff because of her cheerful outlook on - In the Lap of the Gods 23
Does fate decide the future? Is it all mapped out for us, predestined, or can we influence what com - Write Your Memoir: How to Write About What Troubles You the Most
Everyone has a story to tell, and unfortunately those stories aren't always pleasant. What makes me - How Crafty Word Order Can Instantly Improve Your Writing
by Philip Yaffe I am usually very reticent about offering writing tips. Unless they are linked to - You Say Grandpa, I Say Deda
I was born with two grandmothers but only one grandfather. In nature's rules of familial supply and - My Russian American Dichotomy
I was a Russian girl and an American teenager. I had no choice about the first but I tried very har - In the Lap of the Gods 22
This is just an explanation for those who have read some of the other Chapters of, "In the Lap of t - Write a Book: 8 Reasons You Should Do it
Studies have shown that 82% of people want to write a book, but few of these actually ever achieve - Book Review: the Book of Common Prayer
Book Review: The Book of Common Prayer, "My carry-with-me copy is this size, and I recommend it for
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Real Estate Investment - Investing In Commercial Properties
As in any other type of investment, its obviously advisable to do your research well so that the pro - Taking Care Of Acne Prone Skin With Proper Skin Care Products
Although acne has been largely associated with teeners and puberty, the condition is not only confin - Do I Really Need Eight Hours Of Sleep Each Night?
What if you were told that there is no definitive answer for why we need to sleep? Your initial reac - How to Improve Your FICO Credit Score
If you didn't know this already, having a good credit score is more important than having a lot of c - 10 Tips for a Magnificent Memory
"Where did I leave my keys?" "What did I come in here for?" "Your glasses are on top of your head!" - Things You Might Like To Know About Card Companies
If you have a regular income and are 18 or over then you may be able to get a credit card. You will - Bad Breath in Babies and Toddlers
If your baby or toddler has had bad breath lately, not to worry. There are plenty of things you can - Starving College Students No More
The majority of today's college students are extremely Internet savvy. In fact, many of those studen - Cosmetic Surgery Financing: How Can You Get It?
Cosmetic surgery, a branch of plastic surgery, can be quite expensive, especially if you are plannin - Article Marketing, Improve Your Ranking With Links
Article Marketing, without a doubt remains the best free formula for attracting website traffic. At