IT Contracts Negotiation-Who Lead-Legal or Commercial
Lawyers should be important members of the negotiating team but not the lead. I also think that a great number of lawyers may also agree with me on what looks like a harsh statement to make. To clarify my statement let me say that IT contracts as a result of the negotiation approach taken can end up being either legally or commercially oriented.
You may say, so what, we have a contract any way and all our interests are protected; but are they?
To reply to this, I would say: There is no much difference in both types of contracts while things are going well and the solution is delivered on time without any technical problem and on budget. In fact in this case you do not really need a contract at all. Unfortunately, this is not the case in the majority of IT contracts whether they being, systems integration, outsourcing or buying hardware & Software.
Paradoxically as it may seem, when it comes to dealing with breaches i.e. Acceptance, Delivery, and Fixing Bugs and so on, a legally minded contract becomes a hindrance to resolving such breaches and getting on with the development in a sensible commercial manner.
A legally minded contract will rely heavily on the Law to resolve its breaches. We all know what it means to go to court to resolve contractual issues.
Basically the users suffer if they were the complainants while the solution never gets delivered and the cost of going to court will be hard to bear. The contract therefore failed in delivering its objectives: protecting the delivery of the solution that the users desperately need for their business to succeed.
A commercially minded contract on the other hand has been drafted with full understanding of all the potential issues and breaches that may occur. Such contract focuses "fanatically" on delivering the solution to the users and not merely getting the money back when things go wrong or involve the court to resolve the breaches.
Put another way, a legally oriented contract relies on the Court for remedies at the first instance of breach, while a commercially oriented contract relies on its own wits to remedy breaches and get on with the development. Such commercial contract states all the possible remedies for most of the potential breaches before hands, thus removing the need to go to court at the first instance. Commercially oriented contracts are by their nature - their own court and judge. Of course both contracts have to be governed in the end by the laws of land and eventually if all goes wrong and all remedies failed, the Courts and Judges must decide.
Copyright 2007 - Osama El-Kadi
Related Tags: negotiation, legal, commercial, negotiation expert, contract negotiation, stratgic negotiation
About the Author
Osama El-Kadi is an International Strategic Negotiation Expert & Motivational Speaker Specializes in utilising Sun Tzu Art of War strategies in a unique and advanced strategic negotiation consulting, seminars, and training for organisations worldwide.
Osama El-Kadi career spans 28 years within UK based blue chip corporate companies. Starting from a Computer Analyst Programmer at NCR, to Chief Architect for worldwide banking systems, to Sales Director for CAI Europe, to General Manager Technology at the House of Fraser Group (including Harrods), to managing group procurement functions for the Automobile Association (the AA) through to his most recent position as Chief Procurement Officer in the Centrica Plc group of companies in the United Kingdom.
Please See Also:
http://www.elkadiconsulting.comFind in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- North Minneapolis 2009 - "40/40/40 Community Benefits Agreement" Must be a Part of Business as Usual to Help Community Growth
"If it's not growing, it's going to die." ...Michael Eisner In 2009 north Minneapolis community
- Negotiation Probes
Your negotiating leverage is determined by how much you know about the other party's attitudes, pre
- Keep Negotiating Tactics Flexible
There is no right negotiating tactic if you have the wrong strategy or policy. Strategic objectiv
- Resist Like Water
The Chinese have a saying, "It is well to resist like water." When water is put under pressure or
- Negotiating Threats
Have you ever been threatened during a negotiation? You probably have received more negotiating thr
- Lyons & Wolivar, Inc. (l&w Investigations) to Teams Up With Smith & Brink at Iasiu Expo
WESTBOROUGH, MASSACHUSETTS...L&W Investigations, the foremost private investigations company specia
- Negotiating Starts With Assumptions
Most negotiations start with both sides having a set of assumptions regarding what the other side w
- How Do You Respond to a "take it or Leave It" Demand?
What do you do when the other party gives you a firm but polite "take-it-or-leave-it"? There are op
- Why You Should Have It In Writing
There is an old saying in the West that says that if the preacher talks too much about stealing, be
- How to Get a Fair Insurance Settlement
Natural disasters such as wildfires, hurricanes, tornados, and floods have been making headlines.
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Ecological Negotiation
Negotiation is a process of trying to arrive at a mutually agreeable conclusion about something. It
- How to Negotiate Like A Pro In Long-term Negotiations
Ever notice that negotiations usually go much better when there is a history of trust from previous
- The Gender Blenders-How Successful Men and Women Mix-It-Up in Negotiation
Our early ancestors settled on a division of labor, dictated largely by biological necessity: The wo
- Let's Just Split it Down the Middle
Everybody's Used ItIn the realm of give and take it's almost genetic. On every continent, in every c
- The Art of Negotiation, Investing in ART, Investing in YOU, Its About the MONEY Honey! Part One
As an artist it is hard to not feel flattered when approached by a gallery. If you are a profession
- The Art of Negotiation, Investing in ART, Investing in YOU, Its About the MONEY Honey! Part Two
Part Two:Ask questions, sheesh, never be afraid to ask questions.Don't be intimidated by people, the
- Effective Questioning in Negotiation
Effective questioning is a powerful and often underused skill in negotiation. Asking questions has m
- I Wonder Why Do Procurement Departments Still Exist Today?
I am amazed that it is taking such a long a time for procurement departments of indirect goods and s
- How To Structure A Negotiation
People who are successful negotiators, always have a well thought out strategy before entering into
- Warning: Don't Cut Prices If You Want To Stay In Business
If you're in the business of sales, you probably know that making sales isn't easy. It gets even ha