Middle Zone Standard Study Of Handwriting
There are 3 zones in English writing: Upper (l,h,t,b,etc.), Middle (a,m,n,o,u,e,i,s,v,c,r,w,x,z), and Lower (f,g,j,p,y). The middle zone dominates handwritten expression accounting for over 80 per cent of zonal space. It's the core of the personality expression. The "accepted" standard of 1/8th (.125) inch in some literature and 3 mm in other literature was questioned. A search carried out by the author found no supporting statistics to substantiate that concept. Therefore, a research study was initiated to assess an average (or standard) middle zone size, in general.
Two studies were conducted twenty years apart. The information was taken from continuously measured MZ data (normally performed) over that period of time. In other words, all samples had MZ measurements taken for that 20 years with data stored or recorded.
The first study was performed during the years 1978-1979 and involved 500 handwriting specimens. These samples were selected from individuals of 19 years of age and older. There were 250 samples each of males and females. Specimens were not used if the handwriting reflected aging or infirmities. A calibrated, documented caliper capable of measuring in increments of .0005 inch, traceable to the United States national bureau of standards, NIST, was used in the measurement process along with a scientific calculator. Five measurements were made on each of the 500 samples. The measurements were made in the following manner: one from the top of the display, three from the middle of the display and a final one from the end of the display. These measurements were tediously taken at random and recorded. Measurements were made of the down strokes of Middle Zone letters including the slant - not just the vertical height. This must be done because the full length of the down stroke represents the writer and with a 30-degree slant vertical measurement would be erroneous by 100%. A total of 2,500 measurements were recorded.
The second study was performed during the years 1999-2000 and involved 231 handwriting specimens. These samples came from individuals located throughout the United States of America and were received by way of conducting handwriting analyses for either business or personal purposes. There was an approximately equal distribution of males and females. This time a digital, calibrated caliper, connected to a statistical mini-computer, was utilized. This enabled the author to increase ease of sampling in very accurate increments of .0005 inch and traceable to NIST with calibrated, documented instrumentation. This afforded quick and numerous measurements. Over 60 random measurements were made on each sample. Calculated as closely as possible, a total of 13,860 measurements were recorded.
The results tend to be skewed significantly below the generally accepted standards of 1/8th of an inch or 3-mm. Table 1 gives the results from study one and Table 2 gives the results from the second study. The correlation (r) of the two studies is .936, which is extremely high and tends to suggest the consistency between both studies. In the first study, 86.2% of observations were below 1/8th (.125) inch and, in the second study, 78% were below 1/8th inch. Furthermore, the percent below 3-mm (.1182 inch) in both studies was 82% and 72.2%, time respective.
- The medians were .100 inch and .094 inch. Again, tending well below 3 mm.
- The standard deviations were exactly the same to 4 places but not beyond. This seemed highly improbable but was checked.
- The modes were less than .100 inch with one exactly the same (.086 inch).
Table 1 1978-1979 Study Results
Intervals for Middle Zone Size in Inches (in) Frequency of Measurement in each Interval Percent of Frequency in each Interval
.039 or Less 0 0
.040-.049 5 1.0
.050-.059 17 3.4
.060-.069 27 5.4
.070-.079 66 13.2
.080-.089 92 18.4
.090-.099 86 17.2
.100-.109 63 12.6
.110-.119 57 11.4
.120-.129 35 7.0
.130-.139 20 4.0
.140-.149 13 2.6
.150-.159 8 1.6
.160-.169 2 .4
.170+ 9 1.8
Total Samples (N)
Standard Deviation .0264237
Mode(s) (14 each) .086 & .094
Correlation to "99-'00 Study (r) = .936
Number of measures 500 x 5 = 2500
Table 2 - 1999-2000 Study Results
Intervals for Middle Zone Size in Inches (in) Frequency in each Interval Percent in each Interval Standard Deviation Array Frequency
% of each Standard Deviation
.039 or Less 0 0 .005 1 .416
.040-.049 1 .43 .006 0 0
.050-.059 3 1.29 .007 0 0
.060-.069 8 3.46 .008 3 1.250
.070-.079 23 9.95 .009 2 .833
.080-.089 38 16.45 .010 5 2.083
.090-.099 35 15.15 .011 6 2.500
.100-.109 37 16.01 .012 16 6.666
.110-.119 22 9.52 .013 15 6.250
.120-.129 23 9.95 .014 19 7.916
.130-.139 13 5.62 .015 18 7.500
.140-.149 9 3.89 .016 23 9.583
.150-.159 6 2.59 .017 11 4.583
.160-.169 6 2.59 .018 15 6.250
.170+ 7 3.03 .019 10 4.166
.020 14 5.833
Total smp (N) 231* 99.93 .021 16 6.666
Average .10451 .022 3 1.250
Standard Dev. .02644 .023 14 5.833
Median .100 .024 3 1.250
Mode (7) .086 .025 12 5.000
Correlate to .026 9 3.750
"78-"79 Study .027 3 1.250
(r) = .936 .028 3 1.250
Number meas. 231x60 = .029 0 0
13,860 .030 1 .416
.031 2 .833
.032 3 1.250
.033 4 1.666
.034 1 .416
.035 1 .416
.036 4 1.666
.037 0 0
.038 0 0
.039 1 .416
.040 1 .416
.050+ 1 .416
Totals 240* 99.989
Discussion and Conclusion
Although these studies were conducted 21 years apart they demonstrate a correlation to size distribution of (r) .936. Aside from the measurements documented in this report, over 600,000 individual MZ measurements were made by the author since 1977 as standard practice on all analyses. Those measurements continue to reflect the results of these studies.
The overall conclusion tends to indicate that the standard (or average MZ size) is significantly less than the arbitrary 3 mm. The author has used the .098511 inch standard as the "fulcrum" for assessing middle zone size relationships. The studies tend to indicate repeatability, which is the basis for scientific investigation. Similar studies in every country are encouraged to establish a world standard or individual national standards.
A further observation
Additionally, the author has been intrigued by the possibility (and, in the absence of any publication) of a polar-concept to handwriting/printing meaning that there are only two fundamental elements that create any handwriting/printing. We see this binary concept throughout the Universe. To this end, a conclusion has been determined: Pressure and Speed. These are the two essential elements constituting the creation of all writing/printing. Both range from a possible zero value to the capacity of the writer. Some basic explanations are warranted since questions are certain to arise.
A dot or period is the simplest form of speed (moving down) and pressure (against the resistance of the surface). If it is true for a dot then it is true for all writing. Space is the absence of pressure yet incorporates speed for spatial adjustment. Although there will be some controversy, it is the author's belief the conclusion has merit, however, other observations are welcome.
Observations on Study One of MZ Average Size Measurements
Individual Standard Deviations were not recorded in study number one.
1. More than 86% (86.2%) are less than the generally accepted "standard" of 1/8th of an inch (.125") or 3.1725 mm.
2. Only 7% are within the "standard" .120"-.130".
3. Correlation with a similar study ("98-'00) 21 years later is extremely high at r = .936.
4. Confidence limits at 1 SD range from .072" to .124". 66% confidence, results are in this range.
5. Confidence limits at 2 SD range from .045" to .151". 95% confidence, results are in this range.
6. Confidence limits at 3 SD range from .019" to .177". 99% confidence, results are in this range.
7. The average was calculated at .098511 inch well, below the 1/8th inch generally accepted "standard".
8. The standard deviation was calculated at .0264237 inch.
9. The median was .094 inch.
10. The mode(s) were (14 each) .086 inch and .094 inch
Observations on Study Two of MZ Average Size Measurements
1. More than 77% (77.9%) are less than the generally accepted "standard" of 1/8th of an inch (.125") or 3.1725 mm.
2. Only 9.9% within current accepted 'standard' .120"-.130".
3. Correlation with a similar study ("78-'79) 21 years later is extremely high at r =.936.
4. Confidence limits at 1 SD range from .0780" to .1309". 66% confidence results are in this range.
5. Confidence limits at 2 SD range from .0516" to .1573". 95% confidence results are in this range.
6. Confidence limits at 3 SD range from .0252" to .1838". 99% confidence results are in this range.
7. The average was calculated at .10451 inch. Well below the 1/8th inch generally accepted "standard".
8. The standard deviation was calculated at .02644 inch.
9. The median was .100 inch.
10. The mode was .086 inch (7 total)
11. * Recording errors account for differences but have virtually no effect on results.
Writings, Instruction, Scoring, P Velasco, 1990, self published Cluster Indicators of Handwriting Elements, J. Cammarata, 1984, Self-Published
Experiments with Handwriting, Robert Saudek, 1929, William Morrow & Co., NY
The Psychology of Handwriting, Nadya Olyanova, 1960, Sterling Publishing, NY
Studies in Expressive Movement, GW Allport & PE Vernon, 1933, Macmillan, NY
Diagrams of the Unconscious, W Wolff, 1948, Grune & Stratton, NY
The Psychology of Handwriting, Robert Saudek, 1925, Allen & Unwin, London
*Handwriting: A Key to Personality, K Roman, 1975, Noonday Press, NY, page 147.
Thoughts and writings of D Anthony & F Anthony, self published
*Handwriting, An Analysis through Its Symbolism, R Hearns, Vantage, NY, page 36.
Handwriting and Character, D Lucas, 1923, McKay Company, Philadelphia, PA
The Science of Handwriting Analysis, B Rosen, 1965, Bonanza Books, NY
*Analysis of Handwriting, H Jacoby, 1939, Allen & Unwin, London
Handwriting Analysis, TS Lewinson & J Zubin, 1942, Kings Crown Press, NY
Personality in Handwriting, AO Mendel, 1947, Stephen Daye Press, NY
Handwriting Analysis, U Sonnemann, 1950, Allen & Unwin, London
Handwriting, A Key to Successful Living, HO Teltscher, 1942, GP Putnam, NY
*The Key to Handwriting Analysis, I Marcuse, 1962, Rolton House, NY, page 39.
Trattato…Scrittore, C Baldi, 1620, Bologna, Italy
Handschrift und Charakter, L Klages, 1940, Leipzig
Applied Graphology, I Marcuse, 1946, Macoy, NY
Handwriting, A Personality Projection, F Victor, 1945, Thomas, NY
*Graphology Handbook, C Casewit, 1980, Para Research, MA, page 39.
The Principle Trait Clusters for Describing Personality, R B Cattel, Psychological Bulletin, 42:129-161, 1945
*Handwriting Analysis, Thea Stein Lewinson, 1967, page 36, University Microfilms, Inc., Ann Arbor, MI.
*Handwriting & Personality, Ann Mahony, 1989, page 63.
*Write What's Wrong, Dr. Claude Santoy, 1992, page 12.
*Practical Character Analysis from Handwriting, Albert J. Smith, 1920, London, page11.
*What Handwriting Indicates, John Rexford, 1904, page 11.
*Handwriting Analysis, Dorothy Sara, 1967, page 98.
*The Elements of Graphology, Barry Branson, 1995, page 17.
*Handwriting as an Index to Character, very old book, no author or date of publication, London, page 3.
NOTE: An asterisk (*) denotes references stating either 1/8th inch or 3mm as the normal middle zone size or height.
Related Tags: writing, psychology, printing, handwriting analysis, traits, handwriting, graphology, forgeries
Mr. Cammarata is president of Handwriting Analysis Inc, in Plymouth, MN, and has been involved with all aspects of handwriting analysis specializing in personality profiling for 31 years and question document examination (forgeries) for 12 years. He is a strong proponent of measurement use for handwriting analysis.
He's a graduate of Marquette University in Milwaukee, WI earning a Bachelor of Science degree and spent 37 years in many facets of engineering mostly biomedical. He is now retired involved exclusively in handwriting analysis and research work.
Mr. Cammarata studied 5 years with noted analyst, Pedro Velasco. He is certified by Mr. Velasco, the American Handwriting Analysis Foundation, the American Association of Handwriting Analysts, and is a member of the National Association of Document Examiners.
He resides in Plymouth, Minnesota with his wife, Mary. They have two boys.Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- Find Out About Five Tips We All Found In This Anxiety Free Today Review.
Are you in search of an honest Anxiety Free Today review that actually has useful information? If so
- Review: Don't Buy Or Download The Panic Away Ebook Or Program By Joe Barry Before You Read This
There have been lots of reports lately that anxiety and panic is at the root of mental instability.
- Parenting Guide For Child Discipline
The subject of how parents should discipline their children is a perennial issue. Much of the debate
- Counselling With Animals
Grief is a feeling many people experience during the course of their lives. Often, these feelings be
- Are You Confused About Choosing Psychology As A Career ?
Before starting further about career opportunities in psychology, why not we first consider what is
- Psychology School Prerequisites
In the last few years, a psychology justice degree has earned a vast popularity. In fact, in recent
- Children With Anxiety
Many youngsters will experience fear or anxiety during their youth. An editorial in the December, 20
- Subliminal Learning - Is This Future?
This article is a quick introduction to the growing phenomenon of subliminal learning. This subject
- Evolve Your Personality With Subliminal Messages
Subliminal messages are a pretty new phenomenon, but they are slowly starting to take over the inter
- Is There Such A Thing As A Broken Heart?
Most view women as the more emotional ones of the species. It is said by some that it is why women h
Most viewed articles in this category:
- How Accurate Can A Psychic Be?
No reader will ever hit 100% accuracy. It doesn't matter if the reader uses numerology, tarot, astr
- Knowledge Of Behavior
Also known as self-fulfilling prophecies, interpersonal expectancy effects have been shown to be a s
- The Narcissist in Therapy
The narcissist regards therapy as a competitive sport. In therapy the narcissist usuall
- How Do Images Move In And Out of the Mind?
How do images move in and out of the mind? Begin with this. While at first glance, this question may
- The Hateful Patient - Difficult Patients in Psychotherapy
In 1978, a medical doctor by the name of J.E. Groves published in the prestigious New Engl
- Individual Perception And Society
People do not simply acquire knowledge about the objects in their social world. Instead, individuals
- FAQ on Couple Therapy
Following questions & answers are written to help you gain a better understanding about couple thera
- Balance: Entrepreneurial or Workaholic?
A workaholic is someone who has no identity beyond their work. Life is about so much more than what
- Social Psychology: The Psychological Explanations of Social Phenomena
The various aspects of social psychology could be examined within the wide concepts of intelligence,
- Why Does Cognitive Therapy Work?
Cognitive therapy, pioneered by Aaron Beck, is a structured, time-limited and pragmatic approach to