Anhydrous Ammonia Spill Day
- Date: 2007-06-10 - Word Count: 642
Share This!
It looks like someone declared June 8, 2007 to be the day for serious Anhydrous Ammonia spills from refrigeration systems across the country. There were three separate instances of significant spills reported today. Mount Sterling, KY, Wyalusing, PA, and Milwaukie, OR all had releases in the last 24 hours. No one was killed, but a number of people were taken to the hospital, businesses were evacuated, and residents were told to shelter in place.
There were explosions associated with two of the incidents. There are reports that the ammonia leak at a Nestle Plant in Kentucky caused an explosion that blew down a wall at that plant; no injuries from the explosion or falling debris have been reported. The American Cold Storage facility in Oregon had an unexplained (as yet) explosion result in the ammonia leak. There were no reports of an explosion associated with the leak at Cargill Taylor Beef Plant in Pennsylvania.
Anhydrous Ammonia is favored in many large cooling systems because it has better heat transfer characteristics and is cheaper than the refrigerant gasses used in home cooling systems and refrigerators. The problem is that this material is very reactive and is classified as a Toxic by Inhalation gas. Fortunately, the gas is extremely irritating at well below the toxic level so that when a minor leak happens, unprotected people evacuate the area quickly with little urging. A catastrophic leak, however, can overcome people before they have a chance to get clear. This is partially because many people are temporarily blinded by less than lethal concentrations.
The food industry has long maintained that they should not have to comply with any handling restrictions on Anhydrous Ammonia required under various Federal laws, since they don?t actually handle Anhydrous Ammonia; it stays in a closed system. During the regulatory comment period they complained about being required to submit information under the new Chemical Facility Anti-terrorism standards based on the 7,500 pound Screening Threshold Quantity (STQ) listed in the proposed Appendix A, Chemicals of Interest, to 6 CFR part 27. Cooling systems having more than 7,500 pounds of Anhydrous Ammonia in the system would make that food processing company a ?Chemical Facility? under the rules of this regulation.
According to the EPA Risk Management Plan (RMP) guidance documents, 7,500 lbs of Anhydrous Ammonia released in 10 minutes time from a pressurized system (clearly a catastrophic leak, not a faulty valve) will have a plume with a toxic end point 3.2 miles down wind from the site of the leak (Table 9, 1.5 m/s wind speed). That means that anyone between the leak and 3.2 miles downwind could be exposed to dangerous concentrations of Anhydrous Ammonia.
Rather obviously, from the lack of casualties, none of these three release events came any where near 7,500 lbs in 10 minute release rate required for a 3.2 mile long toxic plume. There is nothing in any of the available article that tells anything about the release rate for these accidents, but from the description they did not seem to be catastrophic release events. But what about the explosion caused by the release in Kentucky?
Anhydrous Ammonia is a very reactive chemical, and even by itself can form an explosive mixture when mixed with air at concentrations of 16 to 25% Ammonia in air, though it would require a strong ignition source. It reacts to produce explosive by-products when it mixes with Chlorine, Bromine or Iodine. Violent reactions occur with Bleach or Peroxides. It also forms explosive compounds with Gold, Silver and Mercury. So, while explosions are not part of the normal operating conditions of refrigeration systems using Anhydrous Ammonia as a refrigerant, an explosion after a significant leak would not be totally unexpected.
Just maybe, DHS was correct in setting the STQ limit for Anhydrous Ammonia at a low enough level so that some refrigeration plant users could be labeled as Chemical Facilities.
There were explosions associated with two of the incidents. There are reports that the ammonia leak at a Nestle Plant in Kentucky caused an explosion that blew down a wall at that plant; no injuries from the explosion or falling debris have been reported. The American Cold Storage facility in Oregon had an unexplained (as yet) explosion result in the ammonia leak. There were no reports of an explosion associated with the leak at Cargill Taylor Beef Plant in Pennsylvania.
Anhydrous Ammonia is favored in many large cooling systems because it has better heat transfer characteristics and is cheaper than the refrigerant gasses used in home cooling systems and refrigerators. The problem is that this material is very reactive and is classified as a Toxic by Inhalation gas. Fortunately, the gas is extremely irritating at well below the toxic level so that when a minor leak happens, unprotected people evacuate the area quickly with little urging. A catastrophic leak, however, can overcome people before they have a chance to get clear. This is partially because many people are temporarily blinded by less than lethal concentrations.
The food industry has long maintained that they should not have to comply with any handling restrictions on Anhydrous Ammonia required under various Federal laws, since they don?t actually handle Anhydrous Ammonia; it stays in a closed system. During the regulatory comment period they complained about being required to submit information under the new Chemical Facility Anti-terrorism standards based on the 7,500 pound Screening Threshold Quantity (STQ) listed in the proposed Appendix A, Chemicals of Interest, to 6 CFR part 27. Cooling systems having more than 7,500 pounds of Anhydrous Ammonia in the system would make that food processing company a ?Chemical Facility? under the rules of this regulation.
According to the EPA Risk Management Plan (RMP) guidance documents, 7,500 lbs of Anhydrous Ammonia released in 10 minutes time from a pressurized system (clearly a catastrophic leak, not a faulty valve) will have a plume with a toxic end point 3.2 miles down wind from the site of the leak (Table 9, 1.5 m/s wind speed). That means that anyone between the leak and 3.2 miles downwind could be exposed to dangerous concentrations of Anhydrous Ammonia.
Rather obviously, from the lack of casualties, none of these three release events came any where near 7,500 lbs in 10 minute release rate required for a 3.2 mile long toxic plume. There is nothing in any of the available article that tells anything about the release rate for these accidents, but from the description they did not seem to be catastrophic release events. But what about the explosion caused by the release in Kentucky?
Anhydrous Ammonia is a very reactive chemical, and even by itself can form an explosive mixture when mixed with air at concentrations of 16 to 25% Ammonia in air, though it would require a strong ignition source. It reacts to produce explosive by-products when it mixes with Chlorine, Bromine or Iodine. Violent reactions occur with Bleach or Peroxides. It also forms explosive compounds with Gold, Silver and Mercury. So, while explosions are not part of the normal operating conditions of refrigeration systems using Anhydrous Ammonia as a refrigerant, an explosion after a significant leak would not be totally unexpected.
Just maybe, DHS was correct in setting the STQ limit for Anhydrous Ammonia at a low enough level so that some refrigeration plant users could be labeled as Chemical Facilities.
Related Tags: dhs, anhydrous ammonia, chemical facility security, chemical spill
Patrick J. Coyle has 15 years experience with the US Army, including a stint as a Physical Security NCO in Europe. He has also spent 12 years working as a Process Chemist is a specialty chemical manufacturing company. Further information about the new regulations concerning protecting chemical plants from terrorist attack can be found at www.members.aol.com/ChemPlantSec/ChemPlantSecurity.htm Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- Sarah Palin - Too Good For Us
Sarah Palin has obviously struck a chord with a large swath of the American people, and the obvious - Snoopy, The Peanut Sunday Comics, And Our Skyrocketing $13 Trillion Federal Budget
Recent news stories remind me of an old Sunday Peanuts comic strip. Snoopy is out jogging one day wh - U.s. Manufacturing Jobs Move From Hostile To Friendly Environments
I worked in the electronics industry in various management positions expanding over 35 years. The la - Commitment Vs.involvement: In An Egg And Ham Sandwich, The Chicken Is Involved, The Pig Is Committed
A recent article in the St. Petersburg Times by Robert Trigaux reminded me of this grand old saying: - Get Hot With Athleanx
Remember that song, "Don't you wish your girlfriend was hot like me"? Catchy tune, funny lyrics, sun - "change" To What?
When the boys got together in the 1700's to put America together, they looked back at the littered l - You're Working Too Fast!
"Very often the idler is but a man to whom it is repugnant to make all his life the eighteenth part - Unionize And Strike!
"The worker cannot rise as a worker without joining in unity with other workers and helping all. Thi - Foxophobia, Triskaidekaphobia - Fickle Phantasms From The White House?
President Obama's persistence in singling Fox News out for scoffing and scolding has generated more - What Is Your Relationship With Work?
"If society be held desirable, it surely must be free, equal, and reciprocal society, where benefits
Most viewed articles in this category:
- U.s. Interests Are Imprisoned By Guantanamo
As a Vietnam veteran with 26 years in uniform, I have no sympathy for terrorists. But I am dismayed - The Rule Of Law, Discrimination, And Morality
In an article titled "Places Far Away, Places Very near - Mauthausen, the Camps of the Shoah, and th - I Dislike Bush & Co. More Than Lyndon Johnson Or Richard Nixon
On the evening Lyndon Johnson dropped out of the 1968 Presidential it was a celebration. We could no - The Weeping Of The Earth For Her Children: A Planetary Prayer For Light
"Four years after the US-led invasion, the ICRC says the conflict is inflicting immense suffering, a - You Can't Eat That - The Great War For Your Body
Surprise, surprise; our government/media complex is at it again. In their constant drive to control - "addiction To Big Government" Is It A Necessary Evil?
I was deeply concerned this morning when I received my regular AFA (American Family Association) ema - Uae's Imbalanced Demography Poses Concerns
Even as Dubai's rising expatriate population is being projected as a measure of its association with - From First Lady To President Of The United States
It absolutely drives me crazy every time I hear people say, "Oh she was such a controversial first l - Exclusionary Ideas Of Progress
Communism, Fascism, Nazism, and Religious Fundamentalism are as utopian as the classical Idea of Pro - The Poor Nation's Defense Mechanisms
All the countries in the mutilated post-Communist parts of Europe inevitably ended up poor. Yet, as