HUD Unveils "new" Mortgage Disclosure Rules. Yay! Another New Form!
The United States Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD") today announced new regulations intended to make the mortgage shopping experience more transparent. Whew. And not a moment too soon!
The centerpiece of the new regulation is the requirement that mortgage lenders and brokers provide borrowers with a "Good Faith Estimate" of the anticipated closing costs of the proposed home loan. Here's a .pdf of the currently proposed form that will be required. In its November 12, 2008 press release HUD states that it believes that use of the GFE will save borrowers up to $700 of the cost of a loan. I'm not sure how that works. It's just more information and disclosure, and as is shown below, it's information that is already required to be disclosed by Reg Z and the Truth in Lending Act.
In a remarkably candid characterization of the home loan process, HUD notes that "since 1974, little has changed about the process Americans endure when they buy and refinance their homes. Now, HUD's final reform will improve disclosure of the key loan terms and closing costs consumers pay when they buy or refinance their home."
Like its brethren, the "HUD-1," the new Good Faith Estimate will be known by its acronym, "GFE," so we should all start looking for that catchy new phrase to start creeping into the mortgage lexicon sometime in late 2009. The new regulation also modified the HUD-1 for the first time in decades. Use of the new forms isn't required until January, 2010.
After a prolonged comment period, HUD apparently rejected a proposal that the broker/lender read a canned script of disclosures and other information to borrowers. I can't begin to imagine what the comments to such a clever idea might have been....but my mind conjures images of harassed borrowers running screaming from the room while an automaton mortgage broker drone reads an endless list of mandatory disclosures.
Will this new rule do anything helpful? Maybe. Maybe it will help people get a better idea of the deal that they're actually getting themselves into. The new form requires disclosure of:
* What's the term of the loan?
* Is the interest rate fixed or can it change?
* Is there a pre-payment penalty should the borrower choose to refinance at a later date?
* Is there a balloon payment?
* What are total closing costs?
What I'm not sure I'm getting is what this adds to the already existing requirements of the Truth In Lending Act Disclosures. True, TILA is an FDIC consumer protection statute, not a HUD lending regulation. And that is relevant to what? (For an exhaustive and tedious recitation of the requirements of TILA, check out the Office of the Comptroller's TILA Handbook.)
So what does this mean? What's the upshot to the consumer? Sorry to sound cynical, but it seems to just be the same required information in a different format. Same wine, new bottle.
Different versions of the same information that is already required to be disclosed. I'm not sure what is gained here.
I can tell you that, as a real estate lawyer who has analyzed and litigated quite a few failed loan transactions, the HUD-1 has always been a useful tool. But when I ask clients to send it to me? They rarely know what I'm talking about. To most borrowers it's just another layer in an endless pile of already mostly meaningless paper. More stuff to sign.
What HUD and the FDIC need to do is simplify the loan application and documentation process so that anyone smart enough to fill out a loan application can also understand what is happening to him or her after that application is done and the deal is in escrow. It is inconceivable that anyone smart enough to get to the close of escrow should be so uniformly and broadly baffled by a process which its governmental sponsors will jump and down claiming is intended to be simple.
Related Tags: mortgage, hud, disclosure, gfe, fdic, hud-1
http://www.sfbayrealestatelaw.com Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- 5 Reasons to Buy Jasper Real Estate
Jasper is a small town in North Georgia and it is growing rapidly. Since North Georgia Foreclosures - Ellijay Real Estate
Ellijay Georgia has always been known for it's outdoor activities and seasonal festivals. Downtown E - How to Deal With Blocked Drains
A blocked drain is an occurrence that happens eventually to all households. You may have experienced - The Benefits of Hiring a Plumbing Consultant
Your dream home may not always be brand new, with fresh paint and home essentials. There are certain - The Worst Mistake You Can Make When You Apply to Rent a Home
A whole new class of people has become renters and potential renters in America during the last thre - State of Individual Real Estate Markets
Everybody is well aware of the hit that the real estate market has taken over the past three years. - Thoughts on Avoiding the Landlord Trap
I've heard several people say they would never invest in a multifamily rental property because they - An Idea to Increase the Bottom Line of Your Investment Property
Are you pretty sure that you've already maximized the income coming from your property? If you've cl - Finding the Value of a Piece of Investment Real Estate
There is a lot of confusion about how much investment property is really worth. We'll look at three - Arkansas Land For Sale - Search Engine Optimization and Your Website
If you have Arkansas land for sale and are interested in advertising it on your website I have a few
Most viewed articles in this category:
- How High Did Home Prices Really Go
The U.S. Census Bureau released data on Tuesday that revealed where the nation's hottest markets wer - New Homeowners Tips for Household Safety
With so many items on their ¡°buying a home¡± checklist, few homeowners take into considerati - Truth About VA Foreclosures
Many people now days are finding themselves out of work and not being able to make the mortgage paym - Avoid Rookie Real Estate Investing Mistakes
When Robert Kiyosaki, author of the Rich Dad book series, bought his first property he was, of cours - Finding The Perfect Roommate On Craigslist
Craigslist, Roommates, and The Concerns Craigslist is "great" when it comes to looking for housing - The Forgotten Secret To Selling Property - Simple, Quick And Cheap
Why spend big dollars trying to get people to drive a long way to see your house, when your best pro - Get Amazing Results Selling Real Estate Online
This is the age of the internet. Why not take advantage of the widespread use of the internet to ad - Dallas Real Estate Information
In the United States, Dallas is considered as the second leading state according to the area. If any - The Largest Private Equity Indian Real Estate Deal
In the largest private equity deal won by the real estate sector, Morgan Stanley Real Estate has inv - Fractional Real Estate Ownership
Fractional ownership of vacation ski condos is growing in popularity. Park City Utah a popular ski t