Strong Medicine For The Immigration Problem
- Date: 2007-07-19 - Word Count: 458
Share This!
Like many California residents, I have mixed feelings about the influx of Mexican immigrants who are here illegally. I don't pretend to have all the answers, but Governor Schwarzenegger's recent proposal to insure all children in our state regardless of their immigration status struck a nerve with me as a medical professional (there's a great debate about it on YouTube).
I think it's a very good idea, since even though the parents of children brought here illegally should bear the responsibility for their care, the reality is they are too busy trying to survive and make a living to think that far ahead. From a medical perspective, it's the children who sometimes get caught in the middle.
Actually, I was impressed by an article I read from the Washington Times in the Minutemen Civil Defense Forum that tells of a hospital in Dallas, Texas, that has suggested billing Mexico for the treatment it gives illegal aliens:
"Last year, hospital officials said, Dallas County spent $76.5 million to treat people from outside Dallas. Of that, almost $27 million was not reimbursed. Much of the cost was for treating patients from adjoining counties in Texas, which Dallas County officials claim is unfair to local taxpayers. Collin County, just north of here and one of the state's richest counties, owed the most of any single entity, Parkland officials said -- about $7.6 million. County Judge Margaret Keliher said she was not hopeful that other counties -- or countries -- would pay up. But, she said, the county commission thought the matter should be made public and bills sent. 'If you're not Dallas County residents, we think where you are from should pay for your indigent health care,' Judge Keliher said."
I think the Judge is right about the practicality of trying to resolve this locally, but what if there was a national policy that provided universal healthcare for illegal immigrants at a billable rate for their country of origin? This solution would help deal with two problems:
1. The growing healthcare crisis for those here illegally, both in terms of actual treatment, and the rising cost to the U.S. taxpayer who foots the bill. As an office manager, I am acutely aware of the delicate balance involved with trying to maximize both patient well-being and the bottom line. The two needn't be incompatible.
2. It would force a country like Mexico to create an economic policy to deal with a problem they seem unwilling to solve. Perhaps if there was an actual price tag to every citizen they allowed to come into our country illegally, they might work more in concert with our government to stem the tide.
Again, I'm not saying this will completely address the immigration dilemma in this country, but I think it's a humane and worthwhile start.
I think it's a very good idea, since even though the parents of children brought here illegally should bear the responsibility for their care, the reality is they are too busy trying to survive and make a living to think that far ahead. From a medical perspective, it's the children who sometimes get caught in the middle.
Actually, I was impressed by an article I read from the Washington Times in the Minutemen Civil Defense Forum that tells of a hospital in Dallas, Texas, that has suggested billing Mexico for the treatment it gives illegal aliens:
"Last year, hospital officials said, Dallas County spent $76.5 million to treat people from outside Dallas. Of that, almost $27 million was not reimbursed. Much of the cost was for treating patients from adjoining counties in Texas, which Dallas County officials claim is unfair to local taxpayers. Collin County, just north of here and one of the state's richest counties, owed the most of any single entity, Parkland officials said -- about $7.6 million. County Judge Margaret Keliher said she was not hopeful that other counties -- or countries -- would pay up. But, she said, the county commission thought the matter should be made public and bills sent. 'If you're not Dallas County residents, we think where you are from should pay for your indigent health care,' Judge Keliher said."
I think the Judge is right about the practicality of trying to resolve this locally, but what if there was a national policy that provided universal healthcare for illegal immigrants at a billable rate for their country of origin? This solution would help deal with two problems:
1. The growing healthcare crisis for those here illegally, both in terms of actual treatment, and the rising cost to the U.S. taxpayer who foots the bill. As an office manager, I am acutely aware of the delicate balance involved with trying to maximize both patient well-being and the bottom line. The two needn't be incompatible.
2. It would force a country like Mexico to create an economic policy to deal with a problem they seem unwilling to solve. Perhaps if there was an actual price tag to every citizen they allowed to come into our country illegally, they might work more in concert with our government to stem the tide.
Again, I'm not saying this will completely address the immigration dilemma in this country, but I think it's a humane and worthwhile start.
Related Tags: electronic medical records, emr, hipaa, medical transcription services
John Burke. VIVA Transcription provides medical transcription services to hospitals and clinics across the United States and Canada. Learn how medical transcription works, or compare transcription services. Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- Dental Insurance For Individual Can Be Of Help At Time
Dental problem may cost one a lot of money and pain. But, practicing a reasonable care could decreas - Personal Trainer For Perfect Health
There is a general misconception that need for a fitness trainer comes for novice or from those who - Varicose Veins - Causes, Symptoms, Treatment
The majority of people after thirty notice the changes that appear with the maturing. In this case t - Scenar Therapy - Self-treatment Or Healing Partnership
Do you want to learn about a device which will help you to ease your pain? If you get this kind of a - Scenar - 5 "no, Nos" Of Scenar
Are you fed up with the pain in your body? Various parts of our body seem to ache due to different r - Scenar Device - 5 Tips On Travelling With Your Scenar (skenar) Device
You might be aware of scenar which has become quite popular these days. This is actually the acronym - Scenar Therapy - How To Treat Your Pet With Scenar
There are many alternative methods of treatment that are being invented these days. Lots of people a - Your Options For The Treatment For Appendicitis
Appendicitis is considered to be a surgical illness. Due to its severe character, the treatment for - How To Choose The Right Copd Medication
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease or COPD does not have any cure. But with the help of medicines - Septic Arthritis: Infectious Agents Penetrate Joints' Spaces
Another major type of arthritis is septic arthritis, which is also known in various terms like: pyog
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Drugs - the Last Alternative for Adhd in Kids
Anyone over the age of thirty who has grown up with ADHD understands that there was not much help av - Foods To Eat To Gain Weight
Malnutrition has the same degree of problem as obesity. There are people who are too skinny, they fi - Understanding Postpartum Clothing
The same way most pregnant women dream of the day when they will begin showing for wearing maternity - Kegel Exercising for Bladder Control and Enhanced Sexual Pleasure
Kegel exercises strengthen the muscles of the pelvic floor, thereby improving the urethra and/or rec - The Use Of Weight Loss Herbs
Nothing has garnered more attention in today's world than the success or failures of weight loss pro - A Simple Acid Relux Cure
Many people today are afflicted with heartburn. If they eat food that is too spicy, they get heartbu - Five Effective Household Back Pain Treatments
Back pain treatment comes in lots of forms, from exercise to pain mediction. Standard and most wides - Herbal Remedies - Can They Cure What Ails You?
You've probably heard about herbal remedies before and how they can treat a variety of health proble - Natural Relief for Tinnitus - What are your Choices
Natural Relief For Tinnitus - Alternative Options Did you know that there are an estimated 50 t - Birthing Around the World
Since ancestral times, different cultures showed off different customs and beliefs around the miracl