The God Delusion and The Self Delusion in Buddhism
Most discussions are related to Christianity, what about Buddhism?
Buddhism is regarded as Pantheistic, and sometimes agnostic, so the clash with Dawkins is not expected to be as sharp.
First thing to note, however, is that there are many schools of Buddhism, with very different views about God.
Theravada (or doctrine of the Elders) is definitely agnostic, and refuses to go into intellectual arguments about things not here and now. It focuses on the purification of the mind, which if achieved, could provide answers to the difficult questions. Discussing it now when our minds are full of mind viruses is futile.
It is told that the historical Buddha, an ordinary person, said that he can only point the way, everybody needs to tread their own paths.
This is different from Stephen Jay Gould's 'NOMA' - 'non-overlapping magisteria'. Gould claimed that science and true religion never come into conflict because they exist in completely separate dimensions of discourse.
Other schools of Buddhism believe in certain Gods and Goddesses, such as bodhisattvas, who have vowed to help all sentient being to be liberated. Such boddhisattvas are worshipped for their superpowers. These schools would be at loggerheads with Dawkins.
Other schools believe in Buddha-nature, or in Sunyata (Emptiness), which is some kind of Pantheism, similar to what Spinoza and Einstein believed.
"Buddhism has the characteristics of what would be expected in a cosmic religion for the future: It transcends a personal God, avoids dogmas and theology; it covers both the natural and the spiritual, and it is based on a religious sense aspiring from the experience of all things, natural and spiritual, as a meaningful unity." Albert Einstein
Is Buddhism a meme?
Going further to Dawkins earlier work "The Selfish Gene", where he introduced the term meme as a unit of cultural transmission, we may ask if Buddhism is a meme. Dawkins said that religions or religious practices and rituals are complexes of memes or memplexes. Some of the Buddhist rituals are definitely memes, but it is interesting to hear Susan Blackmore, the author of "The Meme Machine" about meditation:
"if a meditational system such as Buddhism is a meme, then it is actually a very peculiar one - a meme-clearing meme."
Meditation is a tool to be aware of the viruses in our mind, including religions.
The self delusion Finally, the central tenet of Buddhism is the no self doctrine: no self, no soul, no reincarnation. It regards the Self Delusion as a much serious problem than the God delusion. I wonder if Dawkins would regard self as a delusion.
Related Tags: buddhism, dawkins, god delusion, self delusion
I talked about slowing down in a previous post (http://10outof10.blogspot.com/), as part of a debugging process, whereby we apply bare attention and maintain to be fully present, here and now, to avoid becoming slaves of viruses in our minds.
My educational background is in Mathematics and Computer Science. I received a PhD from the university of Zurich. I have always had a fascination for physics, such as quantum mechanics, and biological evolution. My day to day activities centered around my software development business which I have run for more than 20 years. I will soon be retiring from this business. Previously I was a researcher (in Artificial Intelligence, at Edinburgh Univ) and a university lecturer. I practice meditation, at home, in a Vihara or just anywhere, anytime. This blog is hence a kind of intersection of my interests: Mathematics, Programming, Artificial Intelligence and Life, Science and Evolution, Meditation.
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- The Unused Power
Ever wondered what would have already been accomplished on this earth if only a handful of people ha - How Horoscope / Astrology Does Affect A Person's Happiness
When we speak about happiness, it reflects on two variations. One as an emotion like being happy or - Using The Internet For God
Do you have a Christian product, service or message that you would like to inexpensively advertise a - Get The Latest Catholic Church Mass Times Now On The Internet
Get to know the Catholic Church Mass Times through the Internet. It is generally obligatory to atten - Horoscope Compatibility For Libra, Capricorn, Sagittarius
According to psychic readings, people under this horoscope signs are somewhat different and somewhat - Know Your Life Through Psychic And Clairvoyance!
Having psychic and clairvoyant readings done from professionals is the best way to know the flaws th - Astrology/horoscopes: Why People Love Astrology
Astrology/horoscopes is the study of celestial body movement. Astrologers believe that the movement - Benny Hinn: India Healing Crusade
Benny Hinn recently conducted a healing crusade in India that drew one of the largest crowds ever. P - Sun, Moon, Ascendants Sign In Birth Chart Wheel
The Ascendant signs or the rising sign - is the zodiacal sign and degree that was ascending on the e - Zodiac Sign Gemini And Its Houses Description
Understanding Zodiac is not that difficult at all, determining your reading for the said subject doe
Most viewed articles in this category:
- No Sign in the Prayer Test
The recent release of the Richard Dawkins book, "The God Delusion", has brought renewed accusations - Bible Versus Quran Versus Sciences Array (2) the Bees
Before dealing with the topic of the Bees in Quran versus Bible versus sciences, it is mandatory to - Understanding the Heart
(If you wish to more benefit from this article, please read first our "The Alems" titled article. - Christian Dating vs Courtship
Over the past decade, or so, It's become popular in modern churches to use the concept of courtship - Bible Versus Quran Versus Sciences, Array (19) the Birds
The issues concerning the Birds in the Bible are:1) The Birds are Detestable and intolerable, 2) The - Starting the Wealth Process
Luke 6:38 KJV Give, and it shall be given unto you; good measure, pressed down, and shaken togethe - Dissolving the Illusion of Fear
Webster defines fear as unpleasant emotions cause by expectation or awareness of danger. However, - Crossing Paths with a Whistleblower
Mordechai Vanunu grew up in an Orthodox Jewish home but abandoned the faith by his mid teens. He bec - Conspiracy Madness
In connection with the WTC disaster there are conspiracy theories that have been proposed. Such as t - How You Dream Your World Into Existence
Reality is not real. It is a dream. This is not a metaphorical statement. On the quantum level of
