Investors: Don't Shoot Yourself in the Foot With Emotional Errors...Lessons from Behavioral Finance
- Date: 2007-06-05 - Word Count: 877
Share This!
Classic economic theory posits that investors always behave perfectly rationally, in their own best interests. Emotions are not involved.
You may be thinking, "That contradicts all my common observations and experiences in life," and you would be right. Nevertheless, classical economic theory is based on a world full of rational, informed, iron-willed, self-interested, consistent, and efficient actors.
Behaviorial finance, on the other hand, recognizes the obvious: That investors are often influenced by emotion, and that therefore they make illogical, inconsistent, and ill-informed decisions, despite their best intentions to act in their own self-interest.
There have been lots of studies in behavioral finance since the field took off about 30 years ago. The studies--almost astonishing in their variety--have attempted to find out how most people really act when making financial decisions.
It turns out that we humans have several tendencies that don't help very much when we are investing. They skew our judgment. Here are the most common traits that lead to investor self-sabotage:
--Failing to realize that the loss of an "unbooked" gain really is a loss. Some investors only think it is a loss if their account falls below what they originally invested. They view an intermediate gain as not real, sort of like playing with house money. Sorry, it was yours, and if you didn't book it, you lost it.
--Failing to book a loss on a hopeless investment, hoping that it will come back. This is called loss aversion--people do not want to admit having made a mistaken investment. Apparently, people feel more pain from a loss than joy at an equivalent gain. They want to avoid regret over the loss, so they just don't book it.
--Failing to take on enough risk, and thus investing too conservatively. Over many years, the most conservative investments (such as cash and bonds) do not keep up with inflation. Thus ironically what seems most conservative actually bears more risk: the loss of purchasing power to inflation as the years pass by.
--Not accepting a loss as the sunk cost it really is. This "sunk cost fallacy" keeps you focused on the past and diverts attention from what you can do now to get better results in the future.
--Selling winners too soon (to lock in profits, thus creating a feeling of victory), but holding losers too long (waiting for them to get back to even so that there is no loss to regret).
--Forgetting that the real goal of investing is to build wealth as effectively as possible, not to justify decisions you've made in the past. This can lead you to fail to evaluate your current investments on their potential to produce gains from this point forward, which at any given time is the important question to ask.
--Becoming paralyzed by too many options. This inability to make "choice under conflict" leads to taking no action at all when action is called for.
--Resigned acceptance of the status quo.
--Ignoring long-run "background odds" in the face of more immediate or newsworthy information. For investors, the important background trend is that the stock market has returned an average of 10% to 11% since before the Great Depression. That's more than twice as much as the bond market.
--"Preferential bias": The difficulty in changing an opinion about something once an opinion has been formed, even if the opinion is only subconscious. This causes incoming data to be processed selectively, with supportive information being favored and contradictory information downplayed or even ignored. The end result is reduced objectivity.
Obviously, an investor who is subject to any or all of the foregoing traits cannot be totally rational, even if he or she is trying to be. The Sensible Stock Investor needs to be as rational as possible, because over time, the stock market tends to reward rational decisions. That is, the market tends to move stocks towards their intrinsic values. For example, if you paid too much for a stock, over time the market will reduce your returns from that stock or even turn them into actual losses as it brings the price of the stock back to what it is really worth. Regretting the loss, failing to accept the sunk cost, holding onto the loser too long, failing to look ahead rather then back, and/or resigned acceptance of the status quo obviously do not help you make the best decision in this situation.
Fortunately, we humans can counteract some of our psychological tendencies by using the left side of our brain with the aid of smart tools and processes when we are making investment decisions. Such tools and processes would include:
• A standard system for evaluating whether a company is a good company
• Calculating a well reasoned number as a fair price for its stock
• Resolving never to make snap judgments on fragments of information or hot tips
• Writing out your investment goals
• Taking into account your unique situation, including honestly assessing your appetite for risk
• Choosing a strategy that is likely to lead to achieving your goals without making you uncomfortable
• Making, periodically updating, and using a "shopping list" of investments that meet your criteria; and
• Systematically reviewing your holdings with an eye to the future.
In the end, you want to apply your intelligence and objectivity to overcome self-defeating emotional tendencies in your investing. Left-brain-based systems and processes can help you to do that.
You may be thinking, "That contradicts all my common observations and experiences in life," and you would be right. Nevertheless, classical economic theory is based on a world full of rational, informed, iron-willed, self-interested, consistent, and efficient actors.
Behaviorial finance, on the other hand, recognizes the obvious: That investors are often influenced by emotion, and that therefore they make illogical, inconsistent, and ill-informed decisions, despite their best intentions to act in their own self-interest.
There have been lots of studies in behavioral finance since the field took off about 30 years ago. The studies--almost astonishing in their variety--have attempted to find out how most people really act when making financial decisions.
It turns out that we humans have several tendencies that don't help very much when we are investing. They skew our judgment. Here are the most common traits that lead to investor self-sabotage:
--Failing to realize that the loss of an "unbooked" gain really is a loss. Some investors only think it is a loss if their account falls below what they originally invested. They view an intermediate gain as not real, sort of like playing with house money. Sorry, it was yours, and if you didn't book it, you lost it.
--Failing to book a loss on a hopeless investment, hoping that it will come back. This is called loss aversion--people do not want to admit having made a mistaken investment. Apparently, people feel more pain from a loss than joy at an equivalent gain. They want to avoid regret over the loss, so they just don't book it.
--Failing to take on enough risk, and thus investing too conservatively. Over many years, the most conservative investments (such as cash and bonds) do not keep up with inflation. Thus ironically what seems most conservative actually bears more risk: the loss of purchasing power to inflation as the years pass by.
--Not accepting a loss as the sunk cost it really is. This "sunk cost fallacy" keeps you focused on the past and diverts attention from what you can do now to get better results in the future.
--Selling winners too soon (to lock in profits, thus creating a feeling of victory), but holding losers too long (waiting for them to get back to even so that there is no loss to regret).
--Forgetting that the real goal of investing is to build wealth as effectively as possible, not to justify decisions you've made in the past. This can lead you to fail to evaluate your current investments on their potential to produce gains from this point forward, which at any given time is the important question to ask.
--Becoming paralyzed by too many options. This inability to make "choice under conflict" leads to taking no action at all when action is called for.
--Resigned acceptance of the status quo.
--Ignoring long-run "background odds" in the face of more immediate or newsworthy information. For investors, the important background trend is that the stock market has returned an average of 10% to 11% since before the Great Depression. That's more than twice as much as the bond market.
--"Preferential bias": The difficulty in changing an opinion about something once an opinion has been formed, even if the opinion is only subconscious. This causes incoming data to be processed selectively, with supportive information being favored and contradictory information downplayed or even ignored. The end result is reduced objectivity.
Obviously, an investor who is subject to any or all of the foregoing traits cannot be totally rational, even if he or she is trying to be. The Sensible Stock Investor needs to be as rational as possible, because over time, the stock market tends to reward rational decisions. That is, the market tends to move stocks towards their intrinsic values. For example, if you paid too much for a stock, over time the market will reduce your returns from that stock or even turn them into actual losses as it brings the price of the stock back to what it is really worth. Regretting the loss, failing to accept the sunk cost, holding onto the loser too long, failing to look ahead rather then back, and/or resigned acceptance of the status quo obviously do not help you make the best decision in this situation.
Fortunately, we humans can counteract some of our psychological tendencies by using the left side of our brain with the aid of smart tools and processes when we are making investment decisions. Such tools and processes would include:
• A standard system for evaluating whether a company is a good company
• Calculating a well reasoned number as a fair price for its stock
• Resolving never to make snap judgments on fragments of information or hot tips
• Writing out your investment goals
• Taking into account your unique situation, including honestly assessing your appetite for risk
• Choosing a strategy that is likely to lead to achieving your goals without making you uncomfortable
• Making, periodically updating, and using a "shopping list" of investments that meet your criteria; and
• Systematically reviewing your holdings with an eye to the future.
In the end, you want to apply your intelligence and objectivity to overcome self-defeating emotional tendencies in your investing. Left-brain-based systems and processes can help you to do that.
Related Tags: investment, stock, invest, stocks, investing, stock market, dividends, individual investor, individual investing, dividend, growth stock, value stock, growth stocks, value stocks
Dave Van Knapp is the author of "Sensible Stock Investing: How to Pick, Value, and Manage Stocks."Learn more about his step-by-step approach for individual investors at http://www.SensibleStocks.com . Or go directly to Amazon.com, where the book has a perfect 5-star reader rating: http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/059539342X/sr=1-1/qid=1155381420/ref=sr_1_1/002-5852738-5260830?ie=UTF8&s=books . Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- The Secrets to Getting Low Down Payment Car Insurance
Upon purchase of a new car, there is almost always a requirement to buy an auto insurance policy as - The Wisdom Behind Auto Insurance Comparison Quotes
No one in his right mind would not go for a good deal. In fact, everyone is out on their feet and ru - The Benefits of Auto Insurance Comparisons Florida
Insurance can be expensive. This is something everyone knows about especially in the sunny state of - Auto Insurance Florida: The No-Fault Policy
There are different kinds of car insurance offered by a wide range of providers today. Different sta - Finding the Cheapest Auto Insurance Companies
Everyone is asking and searching for the cheapest auto insurance companies available today. Consider - How do You Compare Private Health Insurance Cover in Australia?
Deciding what is the best and most affordable private health insurance cover can be easy if you take - How Payment Protection Insurance Was Mis-Sold
For over six years the issue of Payment Protection Insurance (PPI) and how it was mis-sold to custom - Finding Quotes For Auto Insurance Online
One of the many concerns when you are shopping for auto insurance is being able to get access to quo - How You Can Find the Best Auto Insurance Online
When it comes to renewing your car insurance you are going to quickly discover that there are a numb - Guidelines For Searching For Auto Insurance Online
The internet can be a great source of discounts and values related to auto insurance. However, many
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Trading Forex With Pivot Points
Forex Pivot Point Trading are used today by Forex Traders and are calculated on the previous days mo - Where To Search For Free Grants
Where do you look for free grants? The search must be thorough or it could be an exercise in futilit - The Connection Between High Blood Pressure and Salt
We are a society of Salt Addicts. It cannot be denied. When you look at the things we do and the pla - Tips For Avoiding HYIP Scams
Before knowing about HYIP Scams, refer to the functioning of HYIP or "High Yield Investment Programs - Getting Credit After Bankruptcy
Consumers do not have to live sans credit following a bankruptcy. By following certain steps consume - Tips For Choosing A Credit Card
Are you looking for that perfect credit card? If so, you may be confused about what exactly to look - Cheap Car Insurance For Teens Online
Many elements determine a car insurance policy. Car insurance companies look at the person's age, hi - What Exactly Is Free Grant Money?
You can apply for free grant money from various government agencies. But where exactly does this mon - Small Business Owners Marketing and Customer Service
Marketing can be time-consuming, but it doesn't have to be hugely expensive now, thanks to the Inter - Apply Online For A Credit Card - How To Choose A Card?
The best type of credit card for you will be dependant on how you intend to use the credit card. Are