The Political Philosophy of the City of God
The City of God is one of the most interesting films recently released- not merely for its searing portrayel of the Brazilian slums- but also for its profound political philosophy. The title and the way it refers not merely a region of Rio de Janeirio but also back to one of the most important texts ever written within religious philosophy and as the quotation above shows, about political power. Augustine understood, as very few have understood since his remarkable treatise, the elemental importance of violence within political society. He argued that there was a difference between just and unjust authority and that the second was merely the power that a thief or a robber held. The City of God in the film contains merely power- whether it be the power of the police that reinforces the elite in the main part of Rio de Janeirio or the power of the hoods who end up dominating the slum, power here proceeds from the barrel of the gun and as Augustine said that power is the equivalent of the power of a thief or a pirate.
However ironic the use of Augustine is, it is another political philosopher that can take us deeper into the world of the City of God. Thomas Hobbes the English philosopher of authority, argued that without government human kind degenerated into a state of lawless chaos, a war of all against all, with the only conclusion being bloodletting on a massive scale. In the City of God, where conversely there is no justice, no God, Hobbes's insight into the rationality of tyranny, into justifying the rule of the thief makes much sense. The film proceeds in three stages- the first being the establishment of the leading characters in a city hwere the police seem to be able to control the gangs, the second stage involves the rise to power of Little Ze over all the other drug lords- a rise which involves killings and violence and the third sees the war between Little Ze and Knockout Ned (there is a fourth largely unseen stage when the Runts a new gang seize power at the end of the film).
Hobbes therefore can be used to understand the situation. The slum under either the police or Little Ze is a reasonably peaceful place, violence is limited to those that actually take on authority. Little Ze turns to his friend Benni and tells him at one point that you know the law, anyone who kills anyone in my slum gets themselves killed. But during Civil War- violence errupts with a ferocity that makes the previous periods seem like idylls of peace- small kids are shot with impunity, the streets of the City of God run with blood. Hobbes's theory seems to work- authority no matter how much it tends to tyranny is better in the slum than even a good guy and a bad guy at war. In the second instance there is a race to the bottom- in the first the peace may be unjust and may develop through violence but its peace.
Look deeper at this slum polity though and you begin to see the problems in Hobbes's theory. Hobbes may tell us what we ought to do prudentially under tyranny, but he doesn't tell us what we will do. Furthermore he doesn't show us one last condition- by an act of injustice an authority may destroy its own power- Little Ze does this precisely to Knockout Ned- he creates his own opposition. The condition of his rule, its injustice, ultimately creates civil war. In the end we return back to Augustine that rule without justice, rule without legitimacy of some sort, ends in instability and violence- ends in the nightmare Hobbes diagnosed.
This film is like all good films about more than just this narrative of political structures- there are some wonderful characters here and some just analysis of the relationships between human beings- but it is an intriguing subplot to it- in many ways this film about the Brazilian slums brings to light much of the hypothetical thoughts of European philosophy- it highlights how similar tyrants and hoods are, how their rule can lead to temporary stability but how in the end illegitimate rule can undermine the very peace which as Hobbes was clear is its main offer to society.
The original text of this can be found at www.gracchii.blogspot.com/2006/11/city-of-god-st-augustine-hobbes-and_24.html
Related Tags: film, philosophy, politics, history
Tiberius Gracchus is a blogger but also a PhD student at Cambridge- he runs his blog with a friend involved in Westminster Politics and tries to make it an interesting look at politics and culture with a British focus. His blog is at gracchii.blogspot.com
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- John Cena Ringtones - John Cena Theme Ringtone
John Cena is one of the most popular WWE Superstars in the world today and John Cena Ringtones (incl - Batista Ringtones - Batista Theme Ringtone
Batista is one of the most popular WWE Superstars in the world today and Batista Ringtones (includin - Cm Punk Ringtones - Cm Punk Theme Ringtone
CM Punk is one of the most popular WWE Superstars in the world today and CM Punk Ringtones (includin - Triple H Ringtones - Triple H Theme Ringtone
Triple H is one of the most popular WWE Superstars in the world today and Triple H Ringtones (includ - Gossip Girl Quiz: Why is Gossip Girl so Popular?
Hollywood is really an unpredictable world. This is a place where you need to have more than good a - Omg! Rumors About Gossip Girl Casts
When you put beautiful girls and handsome guys in one show, and give it a pinch (a lot of it) of se - Your Favorite Gossip Girl Cast: Blake Lively in Real Life
Blake Christina Lively, a favorite Gossip Girl cast member, is never new to the world of Hollywood. - Gossip Girl Cast: a Glimpse at Taylor Momsen
Gossip Girl is a phenomenon. Its ratings and endorsement deals are proofs that the show has permane - Anime Downloads - Where Can You Find the Best Anime Downloads?
I am going to show you where you can find the best anime downloads. Some of them free and some are - Erase Porn- How to Erase Porn From Your Hard Drive
Erase porn today once and for all! You need to know how to Erase porn from your hard drive. Erasin
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Exclusive Interview - Roger Cross, Former Star of 24
Curtis Manning of CTU was one hell of a patriot, but that ended up being his downfall. Curtis was a - Internet Movie Downloads
With the availability of high speed broadband everywhere, there are nowadays many internet movie dow - Secrets Revealed
Celebrity erotica writer Tilly Rivers recently invited me to her home for an interview to put to res - An Interview with "My Date With Drew" Star Brian Herzlinger
Most date movies are fictional stories about two people perfectly suited for each other, but enormou - Have you Discovered the BBC Audio Books Yet?
Most people may not exactly be familiar with it yet, but a BBC audio book is actually the term used - Nativity Story: The Still Small Voice
The main messageThe Nativity Story is the new cinematic presentation of the events surrounding the b - Download Movie Site
Are you looking for download movie site to download movies and music? Download movie site is a fast - American Idol and All of the Other Crazy Reality Shows We Become Hooked On
Since day one of American Idol, fans of America have fallen into the ever popular schema behind one - Review: Heroes Websites & Fansites
Unless you have been living under a rock for the past two months you have probably seen or at least - Rest Stop - Review of a Horror Film
Low budget horror films are always a mixed bag. For every one which transcends its limitations and