Improving the Internal Audit Process
The time constraints on individuals makes it harder to free employees up to plan, execute, document and follow up an internal audit. The effort to transition internal audits to improvement based, does not make that issue any easier. In order to conduct a meaningful, effective audit that promotes and facilitates continual improvement, the auditor must spend an adequate time preparing. The preparation of the audit dictates how effective it will be.
If we want to improve a process, what is the first step? In all my years as a quality practitioner, I have heard and deeply believed that the first step to improvement is measuring. If something is not measured, you should not expect to improve it. The first step to improving the internal audit process is to measure it. How do you measure it? The internal audit process is a ratio that relates the relative importance of the findings or results of the audit. To keep things easy to understand, let's break the findings down into three categories and they are not major, minor and opportunity for improvement. The three categories are effectiveness, improvement and compliance.
Describing these three factors with an equation we have the following:
V = (E + 2I)/C
Where V = the audit value, E= the number of findings associated with effectiveness, I= the number of findings associated with improvement and C= the number of compliance related findings. The resulting equation will yield a value or index you can use as a reference measurement, the higher the index the more improvement focused the audit activity is, the lower the number reflects a focus on standard compliance.
I am not suggesting to disregard compliance to a standard, I am contending the focus of the audit should be improvement, effectiveness and compliance. Too often compliance is the single biggest focus when conducting audits. There is not much value in finding out that an employee did not complete a form correctly on a given day. An isolated one time event is useless as a tool to improve a management system. The point to remember is that whatever the auditors are focused on is what they will find. If the focus is on compliance issues, that is what is found. It's similar to going bass fishing, you may catch a pike, but for the most part you will tend to catch more bass.
The effectiveness factor relates to those findings associated with improving the effectiveness of the management system. Effectiveness is the gap between where your current performance lies and where you should be or the expected results. A company has a expects to have 20 customer complaints per month, based on history. During an audit, the evidence shows the last few months have had customer complaints of 35, 48 and 55. Further investigation uncovers the largest contributor to customer complaints is "poor technical support". Therefore, findings associated with improving the technical support will improve the effectiveness of the system as will those findings associated with the lack of effort in analyzing the root cause of customer complaints. These types of findings are much more beneficial to improving the management system than one that documents one customer complaint out of hundreds, had no follow up activity.
The improvement factor is associated with findings that improve the overall management system. That seems a bit simplistic but it relates to improving the expectation of the management system. Using the same example above, lets say the customer complaints have been running at about 20 per month or right around the expectation. Further analysis of the complaints uncovers the major cause to the complaints is "poor technical support". An improvement in technical support results in an improvement in the quality system.
A relatively new management system would experience a larger number of compliance issues as opposed to improvement or effectiveness findings. If your management system is matured several years and you are still experiencing a large number of compliance findings, you should evaluate the audit process. Chances are, the auditors are finding compliance related findings because that is what they were trained to do and it is the easiest thing to find. If you dig hard enough you can find an instance where a human made a mistake.
The audit value indicator is a measure that can be used to monitor the health and direction of the audit activity. A continual creep in the audit value could indicate the auditors are focused more on improvement and effectiveness findings or it could mean they have neglected compliance related issues, which is not healthy either. The audit index is a method to measure the internal audit function, because the first step to improvement is measurement.
Related Tags: business management, quality management
Robert Badner is a freelance writer for Innovations for Quality, LLC. Innovations for Quality provides live, interactive, online training for ISO 9000 and ASQ Certification. You can visit their websites at http://www.asqcertification.org and http://iso9000training.org
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- 5 Reasons That a Restaurant Should Use a Restaurant Recruiter
Have you ever noticed how many restaurants pop-up over time but then disappear just as quickly? Runn - Does Money Motivate?
Some say money can't buy happiness, but data shows that for those who can barely pay the monthly bil - Because Workforce Friendly Policies Payoff
Employer-sponsored wellness programs are becoming more popular as companies strive to maintain a hea - EAP Value
Life would be simpler if we could set aside our personal issues and emotional baggage when the workd - Hiring an Expert SEO Company to Improve Your Online Business
Search Engine Optimization or SEO Services are used to make your website or online business popular - Why Safety Training at Workplace is Important
Safety training at workplace should be one of the top priorities of your business. An effective safe - Team Building: Brain and Sweat to Attain Company's Central Goal
Are you one of those employees branded ineffective and unproductive? Reasons might be the sense of d - Security Alarm System
It is a must that houses and offices install a security alarm when we speak about safety reasons. Se - Workplace Safety Tips
When we speak of safety based on books, its importance is next to food. It is essential to all indiv - The Benefits Of Lease-to-own Properties
One of the hit real estate investments today is to buy properties that will later be put up as "leas
Most viewed articles in this category:
- A Map Mural for Your Business
Yay! That retail store you've been planning has finally opened its doors and you are officially in b - Attracting Customers Through An Improved Shopping Experience
So many new shopping malls and supermarkets are put up every year. Many more are already in business - "To Oz!": Leading a Resilient-High Achievement Organization
One of my favorite movies is "The Wizard of Oz" based on the book by Frank Baum. The story is about - 5 Critical Items Never to be Included in Cost Benefit Analysis
When dealing with decisions using Cost Benefit Analysis techniques it is very important to follow th - Collaboration and Change
I’m an expert on change and leadership, but my most popular speaking topic this past year, and - Workplace Gap
In your workplace, are you a manager with a smart group of people and they aren't responsive to your - Leadership - The Proper Relationship with Subordinates
In the army, "the men" are kept separated from those known as "the officers." This comes from the id - The 10 Most Asked Questions of Cost Benefit Analysis
When dealing with decisions using Cost Benefit techniques it is very important to follow the proven - Cubicle Space Planning
Space planning is an essential element of any project and efficient planning serves the dual purpose - Why Passenger Surveys are a Transport Operators Best Friend
Public transport operators who already use passenger surveys may not fully appreciate the multiple b