Obliterate Bureaucracy to Speed Up Improvements by 20 Times
- Date: 2007-06-14 - Word Count: 1038
Share This!
LIKE RUNNING A MARATHON WEARING COMBAT BOOTS: Bureaucracy-Officialism, Red Tape, and Proliferation
Organizations usually see themselves as smoothly coordinated operations, even when they are not. A baseball analogy can help us see the point. Early in the 20th century, the Chicago Cubs team members Joe Tinkers, Johnny Evers, and Frank Chance were baseball's most celebrated double-play combination. Joe Tinkers would scoop up the ball at shortstop and wing it to Evers covering second base. Evers would touch the bag or tag the runner sliding towards him, then snap the ball to Frank Chance on first before the batter arrived at the bag. "Tinkers to Evers to Chance" became part of American folk idiom.
I Like Company
Most organizations start off in Tinkers to Evers to Chance mode. But soon, more jobs are added to perform the same amount of work. It's like having all nine baseball players handle the baseball after it's hit. Runners will be safe at second and first when that happens.
Why does this needless proliferation happen? Managers enjoy the prestige of having more people reporting to them. Insecure managers will use the bloated staff to cross-check for errors so that the manager looks good in the monthly reports. Also, compensation usually reflects the size of the reporting staff. Bureaucracy is just another way for managers to reward themselves at the expense of the organization and its stakeholders. Of course, incompetent managers will also reflexively hire more people when tasks are left uncompleted due to illness or temporary spikes in demand. But adding excess people to a process is often about as helpful as having a marathon runner wear combat boots.
Hands Off!
Many people in bureaucracies find job security in "owning" a piece of an important process. Let's say that this person has to check incoming orders for errors. Well, all organizations depend on incoming orders. Grab a piece of that process, and you'll be one of the last to see your job eliminated. Yet most of these order processes can be automated. Customers can place orders that go directly to shipping. Error-checking programs can prompt customers to make corrections before the order is finalized.
If at First You Don't Succeed, Try, Try Again
Left unchecked, bureaucracies create redundancies that double or triple the workload … and still fail. In part, failure results because eliminating the last scintilla of errors may cost as much as eliminating the first 99.9 percent of errors. More likely, however, is that the bureaucracy is built up to make the bureaucrats feel safer. New process designs rarely reflect sophisticated knowledge of error-reduction methods. Rather, the designs allow senior bureaucrats to assign blame for errors to others.
STALL ERASERS
Standing Room Only
At times, unorthodox methods are needed to help workers break out of their bad habits. A venture capitalist noticed that his colleagues were happy to sit at their desks drinking coffee and filling out administrative reports. But money in venture capital comes from working with entrepreneurs. The venture capitalist's solution: Buy stand-up desks. None of his colleagues were psychologically or physically able to stand at those desks all day. Usually, they headed for the field by mid-morning to round up prospective investments and investors or to improve current investments.
I Love the Sound of Feet Leaving the Meeting
In the early 1990s, Sears hired the former chief of logistics for the U.S. military effort following Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, William G. Pagonis. He quickly halved the time it took to ship apparel from suppliers to Sears' stores. Suppliers who missed deadlines were fined.
Another improvement focused on cutting back on time executives spent in meetings. In a simple expedient (reminiscent of those stand-up desks), Pagonis removed the chairs from meeting rooms. Those in attendance got to the point quickly or shut up entirely. His meetings rarely exceeded 15 minutes. In the past, managers felt that they had to speak up to earn their keep. Now they knew better and stopped wasting valuable time.
STALLBUSTERS
Spot Checking
A high percentage of bureaucracy involves having checkers checking on checkers, a direction usually chosen for the laudatory purpose of effectively controlling the organization. Spot checking works almost as well and is a lot less expensive. To spot check correctly, ask a statistician to help you design a process to spot check. Rarely will you need to check more than a couple of thousand incidents, even if you want to get a handle on millions of occasions.
Streamline Processes
In lengthy processes, orders and offerings sit around 99 percent of the time waiting for people to do the next little bit. If you reduce the number of people who are involved, the process duration dramatically shortens. Cross-train people to do all of the tasks that are needed at each important stage, and you may take weeks out of the process.
Map out how long each part of the process lasts now and who does what. Alongside that lengthy list, lay out a way to reduce the steps, shorten elapsed time, and limit the number of people involved. If your organization is like most, you can probably create a 96 percent reduction in elapsed time during the process.
Today, the elapsed time standard for processes is very short … often as little as a few minutes. In industries where parts suppliers provide the goods to their manufacturing customers "just in time" (just before the part is used), suppliers usually determine what and how to ship to the customer rather than waiting for an order. Billing and payment are usually tied to scanning incoming packages.
Go for Massive Continuous Improvement of Your Most Important Tasks
For decades the mantra of many management experts has been "continuous improvement." But those experts were usually thinking about making 1 percent improvements. We recommend instead that you continuously seek 2,000 percent solutions. You'll run rings about the usual continuous improvement people. The more frequently you set goals and the higher those goals are, the more you'll learn and achieve. Get going at getting better at your most important tasks!
Here are questions to help you succeed with massive continuous improvement:
1. What should you be measuring?
2. How can you measure those areas?
3. How often should improvement goals be set?
Now, get on with eliminating bureaucracy . . . even if the source is your own irrational connection to approving every detail personally!
Copyright 2007 Donald W. Mitchell, All Rights Reserved
Organizations usually see themselves as smoothly coordinated operations, even when they are not. A baseball analogy can help us see the point. Early in the 20th century, the Chicago Cubs team members Joe Tinkers, Johnny Evers, and Frank Chance were baseball's most celebrated double-play combination. Joe Tinkers would scoop up the ball at shortstop and wing it to Evers covering second base. Evers would touch the bag or tag the runner sliding towards him, then snap the ball to Frank Chance on first before the batter arrived at the bag. "Tinkers to Evers to Chance" became part of American folk idiom.
I Like Company
Most organizations start off in Tinkers to Evers to Chance mode. But soon, more jobs are added to perform the same amount of work. It's like having all nine baseball players handle the baseball after it's hit. Runners will be safe at second and first when that happens.
Why does this needless proliferation happen? Managers enjoy the prestige of having more people reporting to them. Insecure managers will use the bloated staff to cross-check for errors so that the manager looks good in the monthly reports. Also, compensation usually reflects the size of the reporting staff. Bureaucracy is just another way for managers to reward themselves at the expense of the organization and its stakeholders. Of course, incompetent managers will also reflexively hire more people when tasks are left uncompleted due to illness or temporary spikes in demand. But adding excess people to a process is often about as helpful as having a marathon runner wear combat boots.
Hands Off!
Many people in bureaucracies find job security in "owning" a piece of an important process. Let's say that this person has to check incoming orders for errors. Well, all organizations depend on incoming orders. Grab a piece of that process, and you'll be one of the last to see your job eliminated. Yet most of these order processes can be automated. Customers can place orders that go directly to shipping. Error-checking programs can prompt customers to make corrections before the order is finalized.
If at First You Don't Succeed, Try, Try Again
Left unchecked, bureaucracies create redundancies that double or triple the workload … and still fail. In part, failure results because eliminating the last scintilla of errors may cost as much as eliminating the first 99.9 percent of errors. More likely, however, is that the bureaucracy is built up to make the bureaucrats feel safer. New process designs rarely reflect sophisticated knowledge of error-reduction methods. Rather, the designs allow senior bureaucrats to assign blame for errors to others.
STALL ERASERS
Standing Room Only
At times, unorthodox methods are needed to help workers break out of their bad habits. A venture capitalist noticed that his colleagues were happy to sit at their desks drinking coffee and filling out administrative reports. But money in venture capital comes from working with entrepreneurs. The venture capitalist's solution: Buy stand-up desks. None of his colleagues were psychologically or physically able to stand at those desks all day. Usually, they headed for the field by mid-morning to round up prospective investments and investors or to improve current investments.
I Love the Sound of Feet Leaving the Meeting
In the early 1990s, Sears hired the former chief of logistics for the U.S. military effort following Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, William G. Pagonis. He quickly halved the time it took to ship apparel from suppliers to Sears' stores. Suppliers who missed deadlines were fined.
Another improvement focused on cutting back on time executives spent in meetings. In a simple expedient (reminiscent of those stand-up desks), Pagonis removed the chairs from meeting rooms. Those in attendance got to the point quickly or shut up entirely. His meetings rarely exceeded 15 minutes. In the past, managers felt that they had to speak up to earn their keep. Now they knew better and stopped wasting valuable time.
STALLBUSTERS
Spot Checking
A high percentage of bureaucracy involves having checkers checking on checkers, a direction usually chosen for the laudatory purpose of effectively controlling the organization. Spot checking works almost as well and is a lot less expensive. To spot check correctly, ask a statistician to help you design a process to spot check. Rarely will you need to check more than a couple of thousand incidents, even if you want to get a handle on millions of occasions.
Streamline Processes
In lengthy processes, orders and offerings sit around 99 percent of the time waiting for people to do the next little bit. If you reduce the number of people who are involved, the process duration dramatically shortens. Cross-train people to do all of the tasks that are needed at each important stage, and you may take weeks out of the process.
Map out how long each part of the process lasts now and who does what. Alongside that lengthy list, lay out a way to reduce the steps, shorten elapsed time, and limit the number of people involved. If your organization is like most, you can probably create a 96 percent reduction in elapsed time during the process.
Today, the elapsed time standard for processes is very short … often as little as a few minutes. In industries where parts suppliers provide the goods to their manufacturing customers "just in time" (just before the part is used), suppliers usually determine what and how to ship to the customer rather than waiting for an order. Billing and payment are usually tied to scanning incoming packages.
Go for Massive Continuous Improvement of Your Most Important Tasks
For decades the mantra of many management experts has been "continuous improvement." But those experts were usually thinking about making 1 percent improvements. We recommend instead that you continuously seek 2,000 percent solutions. You'll run rings about the usual continuous improvement people. The more frequently you set goals and the higher those goals are, the more you'll learn and achieve. Get going at getting better at your most important tasks!
Here are questions to help you succeed with massive continuous improvement:
1. What should you be measuring?
2. How can you measure those areas?
3. How often should improvement goals be set?
Now, get on with eliminating bureaucracy . . . even if the source is your own irrational connection to approving every detail personally!
Copyright 2007 Donald W. Mitchell, All Rights Reserved
Related Tags: business management, communication, progress, improvement, productivity, solution, business leadership, listen, simplification, stall, 2000 percent solution, stalls, stallbusting, speeding up progress, nonprofit leadership, nonprofit management
Donald Mitchell is chairman of Mitchell and Company, a strategy and financial consulting firm in Weston, MA. He is coauthor of six books including The 2,000 Percent Squared Solution, The 2,000 Percent Solution, The Portable 2,000 Percent Solution, and The 2,000 Percent Solution Workbook. You can read about his work on improving effectiveness and find free excerpts from The 2,000 Percent Solution at: http://www.2000percentsolution.com . Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- The No. 1 Rule For Projecting Confidence - Speak With Authority
One of the most important characteristics a person can project in a business setting - or any situat - After the Autumn Checkout European Debt Crisis and U.S. Brewing Rebound
In the commotion caused by the Fed on interest rates come to an end, the "disastrous" for the euro a - Advantages Of Arcade Game Rentals
There are many different advantages to arcade game rentals. Most people need something to release th - A General Primer on Truck Cargo Nets
In modern highways it is quite rare to see truck cargo nets in action, this is because they are usua - The United States Will Burst More Severe Financial Crisis
Not long ago, suddenly announced that the central bank to raise interest rates, the interest rate hi - Niche Marketing Profits - 3 Easy Steps to Finding a Profitable Niche Market Income in 10 Minutes
Like most beginners I was having a very difficult time trying to find a niche market to earn extra m - The Importance of Hospitality Management Consulting Firms Toronto
Businesses and the managers that help guide any business are in a constant state of improvement and - New Keynesian Theory Label
2010 winner of the Nobel Prize in Economics three theories have been labeled as "New Keynesian" labe - Federal Reserve Pouring Money QE2 Unpredictable Fortune
U.S. economist Milton Friedman proposed a "throw the cash from a helicopter" view, while the practic - Fiscal Consolidation Should no Longer Delay
British Chancellor of the Exchequer George Osborne today announced fiscal consolidation policy, shoc
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Common Financial Problems to Avoid
One must first change their habits and not procrastinate. American Consultants Inc at offers key fi - How a Bad Hire Can Hurt Your Business
What's worse - hiring the wrong person or not hiring anyone at all? Companies can become almost des - Joel Comm Is Dr. Adsense
What is Adsense? If you are new to making money online and net marketing, you may not know what Ads - 5 Steps For A Dynamic Wealth System Online
Recipe: Opportunity + knowledge + Dynamic Wealth System + Your Action = Massive Success!!! Step 1 - How To Stop Foreclosure
Losing your house to a foreclosure can be very scary. There are times when circumstances are ou - How to Always Pitch A Strike
As business owners, we are always working on new ways to convince people to become customers, client - Membrane Diffuser Solutions for Wastewater Treatment Systems
In the aeration basin of a typical wastewater treatment plant there are both organic and inorganic m - Another Year Hating Your Job or Loving Life?
Copyright © 2007 Mary Foley I've come to the conclusion that to be successful - really successf - Dyestuff Industry In India And China
World demand for dyes and organic pigments to touch $10.6 billion in 2008According to a study on dye - Cma-cgm Case : the Series of Lawsuits Continues in Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, France, England and the United States
Damietta company case : The series of lawsuits continues in Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, France, England a