Intellectual Property Law - Trade Mark - Landmark Ruling - Test for Invalidity
First Instance Decision
The claimant company, Special Effects Limited, owned the mark SPECIAL EFFECTS which was obtained by way of an assignment. The trade mark was registered pursuant to s 40(1) of the Trade Marks Act 1994 ('the Act') in respect of goods in class 3 (conditioners and hair lotions, and services) and class 44 (beauty and cosmetic therapies).
Before the trade mark was registered, the first defendant opposed the trade mark application on the grounds set out in ss 3(1)(a), 3(3)(b), 5(2)(b) and 5(4)(a) of the Act. The opposition was dismissed by the hearing officer.
The claimant then commenced infringement proceedings against the first defendant and its UK subsidiary (the second defendant), alleging that they had infringed the trade mark SPECIAL EFFECTS by using its brand SPECIAL FX and that the defendants were precluded from challenging the validity of the trade mark SPECIAL EFFECTS on grounds of:-
§ Estoppel;
§ Issue estoppel; and
§ Abuse of process.
The defendants opposed these infringement proceedings on the basis that the registration of the trade mark SPECIAL EFFECTS was invalid.
The Court in the first instance had to establish the following:-
§ whether either or both of the defendants was/were precluded by cause of action estoppel, issue estoppel or abuse of process from challenging the validity of the trade mark SPECIAL EFFECTS; and
§ whether either or both of the defendants was/were precluded by cause of action estoppel, issue estoppel or abuse of process from alleging use of the marks complained of before the application for registration as part of the basis for a defence under s 11(3) of the Act or as part of the basis for a counterclaim for passing off.
According to Section 38 of the Act:
'…(2) Any person may, within the prescribed time from the date of the publication of the application, give notice to the registrar of opposition to the registration.'
According to Section 47 of the Act:
'…(1) The registration of a trade mark may be declared invalid on the ground that the trade mark was registered in breach of section 3 or any of the provisions referred to in that section (absolute grounds for refusal of registration). Where the trade mark was registered in breach of subsection (1)(b), (c) or (d) of that section, it shall not be declared invalid if, in consequence of the use which has been made of it, it has after registration acquired a distinctive character in relation to the goods or services for which it is registered.'
The High Court held:
§ There was no relevant difference between the practice and procedure of the Registry in opposition proceedings under s 38(2) of the Act and invalidity proceedings under s 47(1).
o The former took place before registration and the latter afterwards, but in each case the issues were whether any objection to registration could be made out under ss 3 and 5 of the Act.
o Therefore, the issues underlying the two sets of proceedings in the instant case were identical.
o It was established that cause of action estoppel applied where a cause of action in the second action was identical to a cause of action in the first.
o Accordingly, the defendants were subject to both cause of action estoppel and issue estoppel arising from the opposition proceedings.
§ '…The defendants were precluded from alleging use by them of the SPECIAL FX brand prior to the application for registration for the purpose of a defence under s 11(3) of the 1994 Act or a counterclaim for passing off, as that issue had been expressly raised in the opposition proceedings and had been concluded against the first defendant.'
§ The defendants were precluded from re-litigating that issue on the grounds of issue estoppel.
Overturning of Landmark Trade Mark Ruling
The Court of Appeal has overturned this landmark ruling which, from last year until now, had transformed trade mark practice. This means that disputes already heard in proceedings before a hearing officer in the Trade Mark Registry (for example in an opposition proceedings) can be reheard in the High Court.
In the initial dispute between L'Oreal and Special Effects, the High Court did not allow L'Oreal to invalidate Special Effects' SPECIAL FX trade mark registration because L'Oreal had already failed in an opposition against registering the same trade mark and was therefore estopped from attacking the mark again once it had been registered.
However, in Special Effects Limited v L'Oreal & International Trademark Association (Intervener) [2007] EWCA Civ 1, the Court of Appeal held that neither cause of action nor issue estoppel would prevent L'Oreal from bringing invalidity proceedings against the Special Effects trade mark registration to render this trade mark invalid.
The Court of Appeal held that there was no cause of action involved in opposition proceedings which could estop a trade mark owner from bringing invalidity proceedings for the same trade mark registration. Also, the co-existence of provisions in the Act now enabled both opposition and invalidation actions to be brought in relation to the same trade mark.
Comment: What this means is that an unsuccessful opponent to a trade mark opposition action could now attack the trade mark registration for invalidity (once the trade mark in question is registered) and that such an action cannot be prevented by principles of estoppel or abuse of process.
The decision in this case means that there is now room for a competitor to attack a trade mark application (during the opposition period) and again when the trade mark is registered on grounds of invalidity.
If you require further information contact us at enquiries@rtcoopers.com. Visit http://www.rtcoopersiplaw.com or http://www.rtcoopers.com/practice_intellectualproperty.php
© RT COOPERS, 2007. This Briefing Note does not provide a comprehensive or complete statement of the law relating to the issues discussed nor does it constitute legal advice. It is intended only to highlight general issues. Specialist legal advice should always be sought in relation to particular circumstances.
Related Tags: ip, intellectual property law, copyright law, copyright lawyers, trademark law, trademark lawyers
Intellectual property law firm advising on patents, Patent attorneys, Patent Lawyers, Copyright, designs, Copyright law, know-how, Patent Licensing, Patent Infringement, trade marks, trademarks, trademark searches, trademark infringement, Intellectual Property Law, IP lawyers, IP solicitors, copyright lawyers, IP lawyers, IP law Firm, IP valuations IP solicitors freedom to operate copyright lawyers, patent solicitors, branding, intellectual property lawyers, intellectual property solicitors, IP law firm, solicitors in Docklands, solicitors in Wapping, pharmaceutical lawyers, regulatory lawyers, regulatory solicitors, pharmaceutical solicitors
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- How to Register a Trademark - Discover the Wonders That Shopnbc Offers, Thanks to Its Trademark
This shop turns out to be the most popular and most liked shop that is often talked about in the Un - How to Register a Trademark - Shopnbc and Its Incredible Auction Sales for Jewelries
A lot of shopping today is mostly done over the internet. The internet has proven itself to be one - Are You in Search of Memorable Gift for Your Father?
It is always worthwhile to present your father with a memorable souvenir on a memorable occasion su - How to Register a Trademark - Credit Card Safety While Shopping at Shopnbc
The internet has come with lots of blessing especially in relation to shopping. Most of us will pre - How to Register a Trademark - a Likely Trade Name for World Wrestling Entertainment
Wrestling and in particular that which is meant for entertainment has gradually gained its way to b - How to Register a Trademark - Discovering What General Mills Has in Store for Your Kids
Immediately you hear of a trademark, take it to mean words, sounds, emblems or a combination of two - How to Register a Trademark - Use a Lawyer to Defend Your Trademark or Copyright
No matter what form of invention you are involved into, you will need either a copyright or a trade - How to Register a Trademark - Using a Lawyer to Look After Your Business in California
In contemporary business practice, everyone seeks to be solely independent. There are of course gre - How to Register a Trademark - Discovering Shopnbc and Its Highest Bid System
Throughout the years, we have constantly resorted to the internet for a lot of things. In short, th - Filing for a Trademark in Israel and Intellectual Property Strategy
In the past, many brand owners, both small as well as corporate sometimes did not consider much the
Most viewed articles in this category:
- US Patent and Trademark Office: Security For Your Products, Business & Ideas
People are always coming up with different ways of creating income, it's only natural. Some people w - How To File Trademarks
Various companies, in strive to achieve higher market shares and widespread popularity tend to ignor - The Role of Trademarks
Once you start conducting business, you are going to start running into the topic of intellectual pr - International Trademarks and the Madrid Protocol
Protecting your logo and so on with a trademark is a smart move. Ah, but what about protecting it in - You Can Trademark a Lot More Than You Think
Discussing a trademark in general is often difficult. Why? It has to do with the fact that you can t - Can You Trademark Your Business Name?
A trademark is a distinctive image, word or other thing that associates with a product or service. S - Using A Mark You Cannot Trademark-Be Careful
When coming up with a logo or mark, there are plenty of options. Sometimes, people make a choice tha - Intellectual Property Law - Trade Mark Law - EU - Interpretation of Directive - Trade Mark Refusal
The case of BVBA Management, Training en Consultancy v Benelux-Merkenbureau [2007], concerned the in - How to Register a Trademark - Shopnbc and Its Incredible Auction Sales for Jewelries
A lot of shopping today is mostly done over the internet. The internet has proven itself to be one - Are You in Search of Memorable Gift for Your Father?
It is always worthwhile to present your father with a memorable souvenir on a memorable occasion su