Is The National Association Of Realtors (nar) Inflating Their Membership Count?
- Date: 2009-05-03 - Word Count: 566
Share This!
According to various sources there are big difference between the real estate head count of the National Association of Realtors and other credible sources. Recently, RIS media stated total agents to be 291,000, Taro Systems stated 329,000 and NAR claims a whopping 1.1 million. A spread of over 700,000 real estate agents. There could be several motivates why NAR inflates their numbers and several Theories.
Theory 1: NAR has long been the power to thwart off the IRS claim to exempt the Real Estate Agent as an independent contractor and not subject to employer withholding taxes. NAR has been the power behind the lobbying to have a special tax provision for the real estate agent in the IRS tax code. If it was not for this specific exemption, the Real Estate Company would be required to collect withholding taxes. Would the IRS maintain this exemption if NAR agent head count were significantly lower?
Theory 2: In most sales organizations, the rule of thumb is 80% of the business is done by only 20% of the sales agents. This rule has long been accepted in the individual real estate office. That being said, if you take 20% of 1.1 million that equates to only 240,000 agents; certainly a far cry from NAR's claim of 1.1 million agents. So is NAR counting agents that do little or no business or business to an occasional family member to receive commission discounts?
Theory 3: NAR is about power and greed. High numbers bring credibility but often disconnected from the real world. NAR long fought to control the transaction between the buyer and seller. This practice held true until the internet let the cat out of the bag (control of homes for sale information). Through the internet the consumer can get free information from ViewMyListing.com, Realtor.com, Trulia.com, Zillow.com, Century21.com, Coldwellbanker.com, Remax.com and all 850 individual Board of Realtors. Let's face it, NAR has long lost the battle of control of the information, but still have not recognized it yet.
Theory 4: Most Sellers that employed the use a Real estate agent have many things in common. How little we actually saw our agent and when inquiring on the status, only to be told they were working on it. I know there is a vast amount of labor that goes into selling a home but the agents all to often fail to communication their activity. So sellers assume that their agent is lazy and only in it for the commission. Large agent head count can make one think that a single bad experience was an exception and assume with the other 1,099,999 agents they don't have the same problem of lack of communication. Again deception by large numbers!.
Theory 5: A substantial revenue stream to NAR is affiliate memberships, sponsored partnerships and National Trade Show conference revenue. Inflating Head counts misleads advertisers to believe in a higher return on investment and therefore spend more dollars in advertising, booth space and all the ala carte marketing material required from a single source. Is this much different from Bernard Madoff pozie scheme? In either case both are very misleading to all.
So what theories support NAR's motive. How about all five! If NAR maintains such a strict code of ethics, then why did they not rat out the irresponsible lending, appraisal and mortgage practices that has sent this country into turmoil.
Douglas Lee
CEO, Taro System, Inc.
Grand Rapids MI
www.taronetwork.com
Theory 1: NAR has long been the power to thwart off the IRS claim to exempt the Real Estate Agent as an independent contractor and not subject to employer withholding taxes. NAR has been the power behind the lobbying to have a special tax provision for the real estate agent in the IRS tax code. If it was not for this specific exemption, the Real Estate Company would be required to collect withholding taxes. Would the IRS maintain this exemption if NAR agent head count were significantly lower?
Theory 2: In most sales organizations, the rule of thumb is 80% of the business is done by only 20% of the sales agents. This rule has long been accepted in the individual real estate office. That being said, if you take 20% of 1.1 million that equates to only 240,000 agents; certainly a far cry from NAR's claim of 1.1 million agents. So is NAR counting agents that do little or no business or business to an occasional family member to receive commission discounts?
Theory 3: NAR is about power and greed. High numbers bring credibility but often disconnected from the real world. NAR long fought to control the transaction between the buyer and seller. This practice held true until the internet let the cat out of the bag (control of homes for sale information). Through the internet the consumer can get free information from ViewMyListing.com, Realtor.com, Trulia.com, Zillow.com, Century21.com, Coldwellbanker.com, Remax.com and all 850 individual Board of Realtors. Let's face it, NAR has long lost the battle of control of the information, but still have not recognized it yet.
Theory 4: Most Sellers that employed the use a Real estate agent have many things in common. How little we actually saw our agent and when inquiring on the status, only to be told they were working on it. I know there is a vast amount of labor that goes into selling a home but the agents all to often fail to communication their activity. So sellers assume that their agent is lazy and only in it for the commission. Large agent head count can make one think that a single bad experience was an exception and assume with the other 1,099,999 agents they don't have the same problem of lack of communication. Again deception by large numbers!.
Theory 5: A substantial revenue stream to NAR is affiliate memberships, sponsored partnerships and National Trade Show conference revenue. Inflating Head counts misleads advertisers to believe in a higher return on investment and therefore spend more dollars in advertising, booth space and all the ala carte marketing material required from a single source. Is this much different from Bernard Madoff pozie scheme? In either case both are very misleading to all.
So what theories support NAR's motive. How about all five! If NAR maintains such a strict code of ethics, then why did they not rat out the irresponsible lending, appraisal and mortgage practices that has sent this country into turmoil.
Douglas Lee
CEO, Taro System, Inc.
Grand Rapids MI
www.taronetwork.com
Related Tags: homes for sale, real estate agent, real estate software
About Taro Systems, Inc. Headquartered in Grand Rapids, Michigan, providing technology solutions for over 27 years. "Our success formula is literally in our name "TARO", an acronym for (T)echnology, (A)ligned with, (R)elationships, for (O)utstanding customer service. Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- When Did The Term "racist" Turn Into A Political Tactic?
I had always thought that being a racist was a bad thing. The dictionary defines a racist as someone - Best Choice For You And Me - Palin, Tea And The Gop
Tea Party backed Christine O'Donnell's spectacular win in Delaware combined with others around the n - The International Response To Plastic Bags
Americans overwhelmingly choose plastic. Per year they use around 90 million plastic versus 5 billio - Using Comparative Effectiveness Research To Examine And Improve Health Care Reform
Our understanding of the effectiveness of healthcare interventions continues to grow - in particular - Landslides' Avalanche Of Mud.
When China observed a day of mourning on 15th August 2010 for the victims of the previous week's dea - The Fed's Role In Crisis And Recovery
Despite its apolitical mandate, the Federal Reserve remains one of the most politically sensitive in - Relocation Of 330,000 Residents Begins In Central China
In the country's largest relocation program since the Three Gorges Dam, China has ordered over 330,0 - China Launches Global English News Channel
The Chinese government owned news agency - Xinhua has started broadcasting events happening in China - After Hitting Record Lows Mortgage Rates Fall Again
The 30 year rate dropped this week from 4.69 to 4.58. This is quite a large drop for a week. What ma - U.n. Report: India And China Massively Improving Slums
China and India have improved the lives of more slum dwellers than any other country, the United Nat
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Campaign Time Again
Politicians are everywhere once more. They're on television, radio, billboards, the Internet and on - Salman Rushdie The Sensitive Prophet And Juma Gul
Between Danish cartoons and Rushdie's "Satanic Verses" that have raised the ire of Muslims worldwide - The Fight For La'au Point
There is a battle between the largest private landowner of Moloka'i (the Moloka'i Ranch) and the nat - Is Charles, The Prince Of Wales, Fit To Be King?
Charles Philip Arthur George Windsor named at his birth on the 14th of November 1948. Charles, the e - The Web And The 2008 Presidential Race
A lot of people have expressed that there is too much buzz on the upcoming 2008 presidential race. T - The Theory Of Globalization And Its Analysis
There has been considerable academic debate concerning the emergence and meaning of globalisation wi - High Fives To The Modern Day Colonists
The colonists from the 1700's would be giving the modern day colonists high fives for their spirit a - Isn't Your Job Mindset Suffocating You, Your Dreams, And Your Goals?
The chains of the corporate mindset holds people back from stepping forward and completely creating - Book On Bihar
There is one thing that I really despise - is the fact that people do raise eyebrows when you utter - End Of The World 12 21 2012
Can you imagine in 999 A.D. how many predictions that the world would come to an end there might be?