Social Marketing Failures - Case Studies
ial Media Marketing is a powerful tool, but also is hard to control. This article features a couple recent cases in which social marketing has failed or gone wrong.
The Wal-Mart case
In August 2007, Wal-Mart started its own Facebook profile, aimed on students. The goal was to stimulate the consumer behavior of students on their student rooms. After a few weeks the original goal of the ‘Wal-Mart Roommate Style Match' was far forgotten.
Visitors of Wal-Mart's room decoration page can leave comments; a function intended to receive praise on the decoration tool, or a few suggestions for improvement at worst. Wal-Mart did probably not expect to have their complete Facebook Wall filled with criticism on its low wages, aversion to trade unions and unhealthy competition practices.
Marketers should keep this in mind when offering customers the option to make their opinions public. You could have many satisfied customers, but when you expect a small group of ‘brand terrorists' to vent their frustrations for the whole world to see, you might want to think twice about opening a brand page on a social network site.
One of the visitors said Wal-Mart's biggest mistake was putting a ‘Wall' on their profile.
Wal-Mart - The second attempt
Packed with the experience of their last campaign a new attempt on social marketing was made. Wal-Mart announced the launch of a Social Marketing Campaign by allowing users to review content on their site.
A Social network site was launched for kids on the wal-mart website named ‘The Hub'. What happened was, parents had to be informed of every new registration which isn't very ‘cool' for the kids, although it's great for parents. All content got screened by third a third party, while social networks are joined to express yourself in the way you want to. Next to that there were no options to PM or mail each other. Communication possibilities are a basic requirement for a social network site.
The marketers should've realized that just one stage of child-protection is the best they can do to keep kids safe while building a popular social network. People need to be given control and have the ability to allow two-way conversations to flow without you being the only one talking.
The Molson photo contest
In November 2007, Molson pulled the plug on its Facebook photo contest. Molson's online marketing campaign, in which students were encouraged to post pictures of themselves partying on campus, was "misinterpreted" as promoting irresponsible drinking.
"We need to be communicating with our consumers because that's where our consumers are communicating among themselves. We need to make sure we're in that relevant channel", the company said.
Marketers have to be more subtle than Molson in trying to capture users' attention. The risk always remains that the marketer can lose control of its brand. Molson is wading into uncharted territory and stepped over the line of acceptability with its Facebook campaign.
The 2008 Ford Focus, unfocussed?
In October 2007, online ads were seen about a man who roars, moves and behaves like a lion. ‘Fake' news articles were found as well; "The Lion-Man Escapes From High-Security University Research Centre".
The relation between the ‘The Lion-Man' and the Ford Focus stayed undiscovered by the big public. The viral failed because it was too hard to figure out what it was about. It also seems to have no purpose - there's no payoff. There are no clear call-to-action events, no ‘go out and buy this', nothing.
A lot of wasted money that ended up in an ad that looks more like a practical joke, rather than a viral campaign. Ford's attempt on putting up a Facebook page featuring the "Lion-Man of Tanzania" ended up having 0 subscribers.
Titleist's fictional golfer
Titleist is a major golfing product manufacturer that created a website for a fictional golfer and promoted it offline using formats like television advertising during major golf tournaments.
Offline marketing for an online campaign can sometimes work but it's so much easier and cheaper to get things promoted online. Although the site really isn't that bad, there's no call-to-action for people to share the content or any incentives for them to upload music and videos which the site hopes they will do. People seem to forget all too easily that good content just won't go viral - great content can and sometimes will. The videos on the site are good but aren't great.
Titleist's marketers should have looked at ways to promote their product online via social networks where they could have gotten their video more attention and website traffic. Don't spend big dollars on TV advertising if you don't have a website to back it up.
sources:
http://lab.77agency.com/social-marketing/social-marketing-gone-wrong-the-wal-mart-case-250/
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20071125.wmolsonn1125/BNStory/Technology/home
http://namw.wordpress.com/2007/10/15/viral-marketing-gone-wrong/
http://www.viperchill.com/blog/2-social-media-marketing-failures/
Related Tags: wal-mart, ford, social media, failures, unexpected, social media marketing, social marketing, molson, titleist, smm, gone wrong
Lifecapture Interactive (http://www.lifecaptureinc.com) provides interactive solutions for our clients that are directly responsible for a rise in sales and brand awareness or a drop in costs within your organization. Each solution is custom to the client served. More articles can be found at http://www.lifecaptureinc.com/articles/
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- Marketing And Customer Relationship Management
Send your notice of rent in time, for free. His Craigslist ad rental unit will be available on the s - Google Fundamentals - Simple Ideas You Need To Know
Google has made easy the lives of many of us by making it possible to search on the internet. But, t - Rss Feed Marketing Strategy
There never seems to be an end to new marketing buzz words on the internet. You most likely have hea - Common Mistakes You Should Avoid While Twitter Marketing
A Twitter marketer makes his first mistake by bragging about his products and services. But let's fa - A Tactical Approach To Social Network Marketing
For many social network marketing involves joining any of the available online communities, making c - How To Turn Your Website Visitors Into Customers
Some websites only get a dose of the cost from the money they spent on building up the website. Visi - Content Rich Marketing Strategies For Attorneys
More then just a smartly designed website is essential in today's competitive online market. To succ - Should You Include Video Seo In Your Seo Techniques?
Orange County SEO experts always look forward to include newer SEO techniques in their process. This - Internet Network Marketing - Don't Give Up, You May Be Just 3 Feet From Gold!
One of the most common causes of failure in Network Marketing business is people quitting when they - As Recession Persists Small Businesses Record Success Making Money Online
As the third quarter of the year comes to an end by September, statistics from the 'New York Stock E
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Affiliate Marketing: Feel The Fear And Do It Anyway
It sounds funny to be talking about fear and affiliate marketing in the same sentence. You normall - John Reese Review: What makes Traffic Secrets, Auction Secrets, and the Reese Report a Success
John Reese is one of the most experienced people working on the net today, and has been getting atte - Internet Marketing - Selling To Tony
As usual, I was scanning a forum the other day, and the inevitable question arose: What is the best - MySpace Marketing: How To Distinguish Yourself From The Crowd
When I checked my MySpace Inbox yesterday, one of my "friends" had sent me a message asking "What do - How To Avoid Internet Marketing Misery
Every day you can read stories about people who have made a fortune online. Being an Internet entrep - All About Affiliate Marketing
Affiliate Marketing is a broad topic that primarily deals with you (the affiliate) selling - Make Money with Niche Health Content
The health industry is much bigger than the internet marketing industry. Billions are spent each an - Why Make Money Online
There are so many opportunities on how to make money online. You can start your own business, sell p - Establishing Your Identity on the Internet
If your business plan involves establishing a personal identity on the Internet, this requires some - Internet Marketing Consultants And How They Help You Market Your Business Online
An Internet marketing firm can offer the push that any business web site needs to be recognized by t