Bentham's Utilitarianism. Part 2 in the Series on Ethical Theories
The first great champion of Utilitarianism was as English philosopher by the name of Jeremy Bentham. James Mill, a close friend of Bentham's and fellow Englishmen aided him in his work and is often given co-credit for Utilitarianism. However it was Mill's son, John Stuart Mill who made Utilitarianism into a viable working theory. To distinguish Bentham's theory from J. S. Mill's it is called Act Utilitarianism.
Bentham used what came to be known as the hedonistic calculus in determining if an action is right or wrong. Here is how it works in a very and I emphasize very simplified example.
Action X is in question. If X is done 100 people will experience an increased level of happiness. (For now we will not worry about how much of an increase that would be.) 1 person will experience pain as a result of X action. 100 positive -1 negative = +99 Action X is determined to be a morally right action with a positive rating of 99.
That is an example of the hedonistic calculus in action. Here is another.
Action Y is now in question.
Action Y will bring happiness to 6 people.
Action Y will bring pain to 5 people.
+6-5=+1 Action Y is morally right.
That one might sound a bit more questionable. How can 6 people cause pain to 5 people and feel good about it? We are just getting started.
Obviously not all things that bring pleasure or pain bring it in equal amounts. Bentham devised a series of criteria for determining the level of the pain or pleasure that needed to be taken into account. Without going into the details of all the criteria I will attempt to give an adequate example of the hedonistic calculus using pain and pleasure values.
You are at a store and interested in a particular item. We will say it's a bottle of scotch. You are hosting a swanky dinner party tonight, but have no money. Being a die-hard Act Utilitarian you ponder whether it would be right or wrong to steal it. Not having to pay is a positive but not a huge one. You assign it a +2. You may also get some satisfaction from stealing and living dangerously, +3. You are now up to +5. You would share it with your 6 guests; that's 7 people enjoying a drink. +2 for each for +14. That totals 19 positive points. Now for the negatives; you may feel guilty later -3. (if you were a true Bentham Utilitarian you wouldn't feel guilt as long as you go by the results of the hedonistic calculus because it determines right from wrong. So this point could be negated.) You could get caught but you reason this is a remote possibility -1. There will be lost revenue for the store but remember you are worried about pain levels, not lost revenue. You reason that the store will never notice the loss. That's a zero, neither positive nor negative. Negatives total 4. +19-4=+15. You go for it.
Most people would agree that stealing is wrong but in this situation stealing looks like the way to the greatest happiness and thus you would be in the wrong not to steal. How's that for a change! Let's continue with the story.
The storeowner is very meticulous and immediately notices the missing bottle. He is out $50 bucks and is furious. He fires the clerk who was on duty. He calls the police who are annoyed at the inconvenience. They recognize you from the security cameras. You are arrested at your party and spend 3 days in jail before being sentenced to 100 hours community service. I could go on but I'll stop there.
Now instead of being a moral hero like you expected you are guilty of a grievous offense. You have caused much more pain than pleasure. "But" you plead, " I didn't mean for this to happen! " Utilitarianism is not about what you meant to happen, remember it is a consequentialist theory. It only matters what happens in the end. So there is something that seems counterproductive about an ethical theory that is incapable of determining the morality of an action before the action is committed.
Another problem is that ultimately the hedonistic calculus is subjective. You may give a particular pleasure a +10 but someone else may give it only +7. Many people also take issue with a theory that would allow the immense suffering of a few for the pleasure of many.
There is the issue of practicality too. How many people really want to take the time to consider all the possible ramifications, assign them all numbers, and add all the numbers together to come up with what is in the end only a guess as to if an action would be moral or immoral?
Still there are many instances when people apply act utilitarianism often without realizing it. These are especially common during crisis situations such as warfare. Generals (and the public) may find themselves contemplating how many lives the mission is worth and Congress may be worried about how many dollars it is worth.
Because of its many flaws for everyday use, act utilitarianism today has few adherents. However you may remember John Stuart Mill from above. He took act utilitarianism and revolutionized it, dealing with most of the objections in the process. It is John Stuart Mill's Rule Utilitarianism that I will be discussing in my next article.
Related Tags: ethics, philosophy, politics, morality, ethical theory, bentham, mill, consequentialism
Joseph W. Kraft II is The Underage Thinker. Visit his website at http://www.underagethinker.com
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- 21st Century High Architecture Or Just Hundred Year Old Modernism
For more articles like the one below please visit us at Plymouth Architects The news that the new co - How To Sell A Car
How long have you been driving around in that same old car? Do you think you want to sell it? There - Sunrise . . . 112 Years Later
Back in 1897, when two Lower East Side rabbis tried to bless the “new sun”—a once- - Allah Has Tested the Jews With Good and Evil Things That Haply They Might Return
Many people do not know Allah. This series (1-78) is an attempt to help them to know their Creator. - Is Reality a Perception or Truth?
Is Truth Reality Or Perception? Perception can very quickly become reality. If that statement is tr - The Unenthusiastic Party of the Israelites Who Neither...nor...
Many people do not know Allah. This series (1-77) is an attempt to help them to know their Creator. - How Did Allah Try and Test the Israelites?
Many people do not know Allah. This series (1-76) is an attempt to help them to know their Creator. - Allah Divided the Israelites Into Twelve Tribes
Many people do not know Allah. This series (1-75) is an attempt to help them to know their Creator. - Was King David Blameworthy? the Bible Says: of Course
This is a new series (1-6) of Verse No. in the Bible versus the Quran. Verse No. 6 in the Old Testa - Muslims Seek the Religion of Noah, Abraham, Moses and Jesus
This is a new series (1-7) of Verse No. in the Bible versus the Quran. Verse No. 7 in the Old Testa
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Should the Individual be Allowed to Speak Out Against the Mindless Masses
So often when someone speaks out to yell that the emperor has no clothes they are struck down by soc - Hegel
At Bern, for the first time, Hegel was left largely to himself to develop his ideas, without the hin - Champorado
ChamporadoI just had the pleasure of eating my 4th straight meal of champorado, which is a low-cost - A Few Words on Philosophizing!
A most peculiar thing occurred to me, and I am going to tell it to you on the chance that it may hav - Religion - A Crime Against Humanity
Genocidal killings such as the ones perpetrated by Hitler, Stalin, and Pol Pot are considered by all - Conversations With God
Words define our reality.We use words to translate the split-second images in our minds into describ - Dorian Gray: Alive in the 21st Century
If Oscar Wilde's infamous character Dorian Gray, of "The Picture of Dorian Gray" were alive today, I - Another Synesthesia Symptom Found
So, the other day, I had another Synesthesia experience. This one was not as bad. Just like the rest - Applied Mysticism
Life has a way of working itself out. In the process of living your life, things have a way of reso - Humanity is Longing For a Picnic
This summer a couple of friends and I ate at a small hobby farm turned part-time restaurant located