Social Programs Damage Character
My direct experience with social programs consists of collecting unemployment 20 years ago for about three months. As short a time as this was, it showed me some of the problems that are inherent in programs which are supposed to help people. Basically, it made me not want to work.
The way in which unemployment benefits were paid at the time allowed for a claimant to make up to half of his or her benefit rate without reducing the benefit. In other words, since I was collecting $140 per week, I could make up to $70 in income without a reduction in my unemployment check. I worked one day per week, which netted me about $65, so I was getting the whole amount.
Then an offer for some work came in. I could work for another day per week and make about $50. The problem was that if I took the job, my income would pass that 50% mark in relation to my unemployment benefit. When that happens, the benefit is reduced by half. In other words, if I made $50 more, I would lose $70. In effect I would actually have to pay to work that day. I wasn't thrilled, and I said no.
These kinds of decisions are common for recipients of various tax-supported benefits. I personally know several people who stayed on unemployment for months more than necessary because it was easier than working, even thought there were jobs available. I also know some mothers who had more children specifically to get more welfare benefits.
Character Corruption
It is hard to make any logical argument for working when you don't have to. It is difficult for a woman on welfare to consider marriage when staying unmarried means her live in boyfriend's income won't affect her welfare check. People regularly decide to limit their income in order not to lose rent subsidies.
These problems are not myths perpetuated by anti-welfare politicians. For those who, like myself, have spent some part of our lives at low income and know many who are poor, the evidence is all around. These are real effects of social programs.
When people are rewarded for non-productive behavior and lifestyles, these become more common. When people are punished for being productive and self-supporting, these things become less common. These are not surprising conclusions. They also do not point to people as the problem, but to the social programs that hand out rewards and punishments.
The nature of the programs is what has to be changed, then. What kinds of changes are needed. In general we have to find ways to help those who truly need help, without training them to have bad habits and approaches to life. We need to reward independence and the behaviors that lead to it, and punish or at least take away any profit for dependency and behaviors that perpetuate it.
The specific measures needed is a subject of its own. They might include training people to manage money and find jobs. Direct aid in the form of food and clothing for children - instead of money or food stamps - might take away the profit incentive a single mother has for having more children she can't feed and house on her own. A system that handed out a cash reward for quickly finding a new job might encourage those on unemployment to try harder to find employment.
Many of the changes required will probably cost more money per recipient to administer than the existing programs. However, if they are more effective programs, they should lower the cost of the overall program in time, because they would help encourage more individual responsibility and independence, and therefore less need for the help. The other result is likely to be happier people - people who are no longer suffering the personal psychological and character damage that being in a social program can cause.
Related Tags: social, programs, damage, character
Copyright Steve Gillman. For the solutions to these Lateral Thinking Puzzles, and to get the Brain Power Newsletter and other free gifts, visit:http://www.IncreaseBrainPower.com/lateral-thinking.html
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- Law Articles - Public Criminal Records on the Net
If you're looking for the safest place to be with this time, you may have some difficulties doing so - Law Articles - Selecting a Criminal Defense Lawyer - The Do's and Don'ts
In basketball, they say that a good defense is the best offense. The same goes when you have to go t - Christianity Articles - Mighty Acts are here and Psalm 150
1 Praise the LORD! Praise God in His sanctuary; Praise Him in His mighty firmament! 2 - Government Articles - Lito Atienza For Manila Mayor - Vote For Someone Prolife
In the approaching Manila elections, a prospect with supreme pro life advocacy has indicated his des - Government Articles - Real ID - Great Idea or Bad Idea?
Real ID Act of 2005 is calculated to fight terrorism, identity theft, and other problems by strength - Christianity Articles - Remember the Law of Moses (Malachi 4:4)
The Philadelphia Trumpet magazine article, Remember the Promises, presents itself as offering some g - Environment Articles - How will the world be affected by the outcome of the Copenhagen climate plan?
December 2009 saw Copenhagen welcome more than 40 world leaders and an additional 20,000 delegates - Christianity Articles - Taking a Stand for the Temple Mount!
On many political and religious forums I post and participate on (just google David Ben-Ariel and se - Christianity Articles - Alternative to United Nations
The hypocritical UN, that diseased body of the dysfunctional family of nations, is worthless except - Spiritual Articles - The Realities of 2012
As with most serious problems in our country, only a crisis of major proportions generates action. B
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Lost on a Couch
"Lost on a Couch" - the psychological reasons for the US defeat in Iraq In many ways the de - Why Should We Fight the War Against Terror?
The War on Terror is getting a lot of attention these days. Most people either strongly suppor - Is George Allen's Political Career Over?
In the wake of George Allen's defeat by Jim Webb, let's not write Allen's political obituary just ye - The Basics of Government Auctions
A government auction is a good place to buy quality or unusual merchandise at a bargain. Government - Freakonomics, a Book Review
If the thought of a book on economics is about as exciting as watching your toenails grow, or you ar - Organic and Fairtrade Baby Food
Organic baby food has been around for a number of years but the first Fairtrade baby food was launch - Controversial Treatment Gives Patient Higher Quality of Life but Takes Away Self Dignity
In Seattle, a 9 year old girl named Ashley is affected by a disease called static encephalopathy. T - The Greening of America's Cities
The Greening of American Cities Today, merely collecting the garbage, running a bottle recyclin - What to Expect from Schwarzenegger's Health Care Plan
After successful body building and acting careers, Arnold Schwarzenegger decided to attack the world - What is Bird-Flu?
Over the past year, Bird Flu has been pasted on the headlines of every major media outlet