That's My Story And I'm Sticking To It
Niednagel gained national attention in 1998 with his pre-draft assessments of Peyton Manning and Ryan Leaf, the #1 and 2 picks respectively, in the NFL draft that year. He stated that based on his analysis of their individual brain types, Manning would become a superstar in the NFL while Leaf would struggle. Manning is the reining Super Bowl MVP; Leaf has been out of the league since 2002 and is now an assistant college coach.
Neidnagel's "brain typing" theory is a derivative of the old Myers-Briggs personality tests that classifies individuals based on a combination of preferences such as feeling, thinking, sensing, perceiving, etc. (A good site for discovering your own brain type is Socionics -- I test out as an ESTP: extroverted, sensing, thinking and perceiving).
What I find interesting about his work is that he claims these preferences manifest themselves through motor skills such as eye contact, voice inflection, body movements (the way you walk, hand gestures), etc., so you can determine a person's brain-type or innate "wiring" without them having to take a self-assessment test. He believes, as do I, that self-assessments produce inaccurate results, particularly when it comes to pre-employment testing, due to a number of reasons:
* Multiple perceptions: most people feel they act differently in different settings. "At home I'm fun loving and gregarious, but at work I'm strictly business." I've had people ask me before taking a personality assessment, "Am I supposed to answer this how I think I am or how I think other's perceive me?" The result is usually a combination of those two perspectives.
* Skewed perception of self: too often we see ourselves differently than the rest of world sees us. Remember the first time you heard a recording of your own voice?
* Manipulated results: Candidates recognize how much is riding on these results and make adjustments to their answers based on what they think the company wants to see. I've had clients that will not speak with a candidate unless the results from their pre-assessment comes back favorably--regardless of what their resume says.
Neidnagel claims that even when you take a self-assessment with no vested interest in the outcome, the results are only 75% accurate. Basing a hiring decision on these results is like heading off on a cross-country trip with only 75% of the directions being correct. If you (or your company) insist on using pre-assessments as part of your candidate screening process, I recommend their weight be no more than 10% of the overall hiring criteria.
Related Tags: resume, hiring, management, recruiting, interviewing, executive search, headhunter, search firm
Thad Greer is an Executive Sales Recruiter and the Managing Partner with Priority Recruiting Solutions, Inc. http://www.priorityrecruiting.com, a nationwide retained, executive search firm headquartered in South Florida. He can be reached at 888-EZ2-SEARCH or thad@priorityrecruiting.com. His blog, "Confessions from a Serial Recruiter", http://serialrecruiter.blogspot.com serves as a resource for employers and job seekers alike.
Your Article Search Directory : Find in ArticlesRecent articles in this category:
- Become A Motorboat Mechanic
Motorboat mechanics are responsible for repairing and maintaining electrical and mechanical equipmen - Become A Legal Secretary
Legal secretaries are responsible for most of the clerical duties in a law office. Their role is pri - The Often Missing Element
I was just thinking about the Summer Olympics the other night. While I can hold my own in a lot of s - Electrical Courses: What You Should Know
Our lives today are unimaginable without electricity and electricians are the people who bring elect - Plumber Courses Are A Great Way To Change Career
Plumber is a person who primarily does plumbing work in residential and commercial areas. Plumber co - How to Prepare For a Review at Work
Most people look forward to job reviews about as much as they do a root canal. No matter how well y - Top Six Job Search Mistakes (and How to Avoid Them)
Many job seekers think that whether they land a new position is a matter of luck: it's good luck if - What Careers Are Best in a Bad Economy
With all the concern over the economy, one thing that people keep talking about is the job market. - 10 Tips to Reduce Stress at Work
Too much stress can have a negative impact on your well-being. Stress can not only cause anxiety an - Career, How Will the Current Financial Climate Affect the Jobs Market in Australia?
Experts are predicting that the current financial climate will adversely affect jobs in Australi
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Hollow Eyes Are Not Dark Circles Under The Eyes
Many people of all ages complain of dark circles under their eyes. The phrase "dark circles under th - Career As A Hairstylist
Hairdressing is an art that involves arranging hair for aesthetic purposes, participation in formal - Life After West Point Military School
West Point exists to educate and train Cadets who are commissioned as Officers in the US Army upon G - Hiring A New Assistant?
More and more small businesses and even larger companies are turning to virtual office assista - Who are the EMTs
You'll find them at Denny's. At least I always do. Denny's, Coco's, Perkin's; any all-night restaura - Tips for Job Hunting in Today's Market
In order to be competitive in today's job market, you must stand apart from the competition. Just h - Work Experience In Fashion - How To Get A Great Opportunity In Fashion Work
Work experience in fashion can be one of the most challenging positions to find. It's a simple equa - Increased Salary with a Medical Degree: Consider the Options
Physicians are probably one of the highest paid professionals in the world. They make a lot of money - You Too Can Start an Independent Record Label
It's no big secret, the trick of how to start a record label definitely involves some cash and most - 5 Steps to Becoming a Virtual Assistant
Here are 5 steps that I went through in becoming a virtual assistant. These aren’t official by
