Hardback Books and Hard Truths
If you look on the web at advertising agency websites, you'll notice that every agency has its own manifesto.
Some take it a step further: their manifestos are printed in hardback and available at Borders.
Books written by and about ad agencies keep coming. Pat Fallon recently wrote one called "Juicing the Orange," highlighting the accomplishments of his shop. And soon, a fly-on-the-wall account of life at Crispin Porter & Bogusky called "Hoopla" will be hitting the bookstore shelves, too.
Unfortunately, CEOs of mediocre shops all over the land will buy many of these books by the boxful. They'll give out copies to management. They'll Xerox significant pages and distribute them to the staff. All in an attempt to duplicate Fallon or Crispin's success.
Save your money. Save your copy paper. It can't be done.
I did a little research. Crispin has been around as an agency since 1965. For at least 30 of those years, the only thing hot about the agency was the climate outside its building. It took time to build a great creative agency & a culture. More importantly, it took the right people-and the right clients.
Could reading one book make that kind of difference at your shop? Could you pull off a major transformation in one year, or two?
All agencies should strive to improve and to help its employees and clients achieve something unique and special. But that begins with an honest assessment of where you are today: What makes your agency unique, if anything at all? What makes you a unique advertising professional?
Here's a hint: you can't be unique by trying to imitate someone else. Simply put, you can't hire someone who worked at Crispin and expect them to spread the pixie dust at every turn. Much like in football or baseball, a superstar on one team can be a bust somewhere else.
Right now, many agencies are working to redefine themselves for the new media landscape. Yet they still utilize processes that are outmoded-in everything from the way they hire people to the way the work flows through the agency. Even in a business like advertising where everything evolves rapidly, new is always unfamiliar-and scary.
It's easier said than done, but I'll say it anyway. Your agency could be the next...well, whichever agency you admire. But it won't be the same; it won't feel the same and it won't look the same. Create a great culture at your agency. Allow the people around you to be their best. And don't try to become something you're not.
Then maybe you'll have a story to tell that folks will pay $24.95 to read about.
I once interviewed at an agency that claimed it wanted to be "the next Cole & Weber" -back when wanting to be Cole & Weber was something agencies wanted to be. Only this agency was 3,000 miles away; from a mindset standpoint, it was even further removed from a west coast ethos. Instead of focusing on what the agency could become, they focused on what they would never become.
Frankly, I'm an admirer of anyone with strongly held convictions about advertising or business. I've read dozens of books about the advertising business and learned quite a bit from each. I've recommended quite a few to friends and colleagues.
Take "Lovemarks," a book written by Saatchi & Saatchi's Kevin Roberts. Now, I don't know if every Saatchi employee walks through the door each morning with love on their brain and in their hearts, but it was recently revealed that JC Penney's CEO was so enamored with the idea of his brand becoming a "Lovemark" that Saatchi got the entire account.
Related Tags: marketing, advertising, branding, agencies
Branding. Religion. Censorship. Office politics. Global politics. Sexual politics. And getting drunk during a job interview.
Since 2002, Danny G. (a.k.a. Dan Goldgeier) has been writing the most provocative advertising columns ever published. They're all witty, thoughtful and probing, and a must read for those who want a perspective rarely seen in traditional industry publications.
An Atlanta-based copywriter and ad school graduate, Dan has worked at shops big and small. He reads incessantly about advertising, and is a whiz at rock & roll trivia. Learn more about him by visiting his copywriting website or AdColumnist.com, the View From The Cheap Seats Archive website. You may also find articles by Danny G at TalentZoo.com.
Recent articles in this category:
- Promotional Umbrellas are a Useful Tool in Branding Campaigns
With thousands of promotional products out there, it can be difficult to figure out which are useful - Promotional Tote Bags: an Effective an Useful Marketing Tool
Of all of the promotional items a business has to choose from, promotional tote bags are probably th - Avoid Stressful Deadlines
I've mentioned many times in the past the stress involved in an upcoming deadline for some piece of - Proactive Online Reputation Management Tips for Companies When Building an Online Brand
With the speed and ease that information spreads on the Internet, companies wishing to protect thei - 5 Tips on Flyer Printing
If you are not familiar with flying printing, you could be wasting a lot of time and money on your - How to Print Great Flyers Cheaply
Contrary to popular belief, flyer printing is no longer an expensive advertising medium. The downwa - Custom Signs Buying Tips
Every business and organization wants to look their best at all times so when it comes to public di - Three Important Auto Locksmith Services for Carefree Driving
Stuck in the middle of the road with your keys locked inside the car? What do you do now? Call your - Tips to Have a Trade Show Booth That Draws Potential Customers
The key to great trade show exhibiting is marketing. Having a strategic exhibit marketing and tacti - We Wanna be Green
Companies all over the world are adopting green marketing slogans and attaching "built green" to ev
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Protecting A Logo: One Key to Branding Success
Logos play an important part in marketing and brand recognition. Take, for example, Nike's "Swoosh," - Brand Awareness Basics
Statistics tell us that in the U.S. alone, the average person is exposed to 3,500 ad impressions per - Corporate Logo Design
A Corporate logo design is a name, illustration or trademark which gives a company its unique visual - Brand your business
Branding is more than just product recognition inherent in the printed materials that they may be us - Small Business Success
Since the inception my business, I have had a lot of small business owners talk to me about business - Types in Logo Design
Text-Based Logo DesignThe mainly extensively used of all logo types; the Text-Based design focuses o - How to Use Ad Specialties To Brand Or Market Your Company
As business owners, how many times have you been "sold" something?This is especially prevalent in th - Save Time Writing Branded Materials With A Content Blocks Document
Recently we helped a small business owner re-write his marketing and business plans. The owner was g - A Push Culture Or A Push & Pull Culture - For B2b Companies
There are broadly two kinds of businesses. B2C, businesses that sell to individual customers, and B - From Lemons to Loans - The Changing Face of Supermarkets
Thirty years ago we would shop in local Town Centres. We'd visit the local butchers, greengrocers, w

