Academic Leadership Courses vs Online Leadership Courses
- Date: 2010-05-24 - Word Count: 497
Share This!
Leadership courses/classes/coaching comes in many names and forms, but the susbtance usually fits into one of 2 catergories:
1. Academic Leadership Courses
2. Experience or 'Hands on' Based Courses
The differences between the two are very stark: academic courses teach the theory surrounding leadership & management (as the skills needed for both can sometimes overlap). These will involved many leadership theories developed by professors and researchers using scientific methods, and drawing sensible conclusions from their results.
While I wouldn't want to attack the work of these researchers - it is however important that we appreciate the weaknesses inherent within this strategy of learning.
Weakness 1 : Lack of reality. Sometimes experiments take place in very abstract and artificial settings. They may help us learn and understand human behaviour, but however it is in linking these scientific results to practical approaches to leadership, where this type of leadership course falls down. Due to the rather contrieved settings - the results may simply not replicate in real life due to other factors that always exist in a business like setting.
Weakness 2: No development for the learner. Learning a theory is certainly not the same as being able to apply one. And in this sense: purely academic leadership courses do not even cover all the bases needed to effective improve the leadership (or ensure a marginal improvement) in an individual.
Experienced based courses can take the form of mentoring from within an organisation, or perhaps a real-life based case study for the participant of the course to take part in, such as in an MBA.
These courses are often those recommended by leading leadership experts, leadership consultants, leadership coaches and gurus. They receive this universal support, because practise-based leadership courses are certainly seen as the 'premium' or '5 star' way of developing your skills and improving your leadership potential.
Being able to work with someone one-on-one gives you a great attachment and commitment to your leadership course. Not wanting to let your mentor down, you will find that having someone above you, looking down upon your work will tremendously effect the amount of effort you put into it. I appreciate that you may see yourself as a very motivated individual - however the majority of us will still slack off less with a face-to-face leadership ooach.
A course that bases its learning points upon the individual mistakes or weaknesses in a participants actual activity is a great way to ensure that the potential-leader remembers and is able to apply the lessons learnt.
Experience based courses are however far more expensive than purely academic - the most convient of which; online leadership courses, can be avaliable for under £500, (although of course, the less you pay, the less you can expect).
In conclusion, chosing a leadership course or online leadership course is about balancing your own needs. Do you believe that you will be able to action advance leadership models on your own? Or do you believe that having a professional with oversight who will give feedback, will be able to better respond to your leadership development needs?
1. Academic Leadership Courses
2. Experience or 'Hands on' Based Courses
The differences between the two are very stark: academic courses teach the theory surrounding leadership & management (as the skills needed for both can sometimes overlap). These will involved many leadership theories developed by professors and researchers using scientific methods, and drawing sensible conclusions from their results.
While I wouldn't want to attack the work of these researchers - it is however important that we appreciate the weaknesses inherent within this strategy of learning.
Weakness 1 : Lack of reality. Sometimes experiments take place in very abstract and artificial settings. They may help us learn and understand human behaviour, but however it is in linking these scientific results to practical approaches to leadership, where this type of leadership course falls down. Due to the rather contrieved settings - the results may simply not replicate in real life due to other factors that always exist in a business like setting.
Weakness 2: No development for the learner. Learning a theory is certainly not the same as being able to apply one. And in this sense: purely academic leadership courses do not even cover all the bases needed to effective improve the leadership (or ensure a marginal improvement) in an individual.
Experienced based courses can take the form of mentoring from within an organisation, or perhaps a real-life based case study for the participant of the course to take part in, such as in an MBA.
These courses are often those recommended by leading leadership experts, leadership consultants, leadership coaches and gurus. They receive this universal support, because practise-based leadership courses are certainly seen as the 'premium' or '5 star' way of developing your skills and improving your leadership potential.
Being able to work with someone one-on-one gives you a great attachment and commitment to your leadership course. Not wanting to let your mentor down, you will find that having someone above you, looking down upon your work will tremendously effect the amount of effort you put into it. I appreciate that you may see yourself as a very motivated individual - however the majority of us will still slack off less with a face-to-face leadership ooach.
A course that bases its learning points upon the individual mistakes or weaknesses in a participants actual activity is a great way to ensure that the potential-leader remembers and is able to apply the lessons learnt.
Experience based courses are however far more expensive than purely academic - the most convient of which; online leadership courses, can be avaliable for under £500, (although of course, the less you pay, the less you can expect).
In conclusion, chosing a leadership course or online leadership course is about balancing your own needs. Do you believe that you will be able to action advance leadership models on your own? Or do you believe that having a professional with oversight who will give feedback, will be able to better respond to your leadership development needs?
Simon Oates advises on leadership courses, online leadership courses and leadership training on his personal blog.n
n Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- A Few Of The Skills Of An A Successful Leader
Among the most important factors in determining the result of a group exercise of any style is the m - What Do Leaders Have In Common?
Who are "THEY"?"THEY" are all the top performers -- the best of the best. But what does it take to m - Lms Mentoring - More Fresh Ideas
Simple and effective LMS training on both managerial roles and staff mentoring strategies are a huge - Leadership Training in the 21st Century. How to Bring Your Leadership Training Up to Date
If you're reading this article, you're probably someone responsible for delivering an effective and - How to Create a Leadership Development Plan
HR leadership and executive leadership training both take a lot of practice and motivation. To becom - Six Ways To Defeat Complacency
Complacency - and its ill effects - is all around us.Consider politics. Democrats held one Senate se - Getting Back To The Basics Of Problem Solving
Everyone has problems. Big problems, little problems, work problems, relationship problems; pick an - Five Ways To Pick Your Best Development Tools
Personal development.Professional development.Leadership development.Regardless of which words you u - Six Secrets To Building Your Confidence
If you have seen the movie or stage musical The Sound of Music, you likely remember Maria leaving th - Are Leadership Courses Going Downhill by Going Online?
Leadership courses are a fantastic way to gain new leadership knowledge - there's no doubt about tha
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Engaging The Five Senses
We were all born with five senses, each one helping us to make generalizations about the world. You - Power Inspires Your Audience
Power is intricately connected to persuasion in that it increases your ability to persuade, influenc - NLP A Personal Development Tool
Like many personal development innovations, NLP - which stands for neuro-linguistic programming - is - Team Building in Bristol
Many employers in Bristol take the vision of their companies very seriously. This is true whether it - Seven Ways to Improve the Results of Your Leadership Development Efforts
Every day we deal with a variety of matters of urgent importance in our organizations. Seldom is lea - Why Most Leadership Development Efforts Fail
George was seen as an up-and-coming leader in the organization. People the worked for him liked and - Occam's Razor And Leadership
PERMISSION TO REPUBLISH: This article may be republished in newsletters and on web sites provided at - Leadership In The Workplace As A Boss
Do you give your employees the type of leadership in the workplace that they come to expect? What is - Metal Detecting Is Also About Obedience
Are you purchasing a detector to use occasionally at a lake or beach? Or do you now find yourself wi - Get Courage and Build Unstoppable Strength!
What shape are your courage muscles in? Courage is our ability to act despite fear. What honestly ca