Three Deadly Sins That Can Ruin A Mold Case
- Date: 2008-07-28 - Word Count: 507
Share This!
Although I've seen numerous ads screaming "MOLD DESTROYS YOUR HOME AND YOUR HEALTH!", and that 'EXPOSURE TO TOXIC MOLD CAUSES PSYCHOLOGICAL DEPRESSION, FATIGUE, PSORIASIS AND 'MOLD LUNG DISEASE!", the current scientific literature does not support these wholesale claims. As a result, the courts have, with increasing frequency, dismissed those mold claims that do not meet strict evidentiary criteria. In order to clarify those areas where mold claims are particularly vulnerable, I have compiled the following "Three Deadly Sins" list that should be consulted in evaluating the strength - or weakness - of a mold exposure claim.
Deadly Sin #1 - Failing to Get Appropriate and Timely Clinical Testing that Confirms a Mold Allergy
A 2006 peer-reviewed article published by the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology recommends that patients with a suspected mold allergy should undergo an accepted skin or blood test for IgE antibodies to mold antigens as part of a clinical evaluation for mold allergies. The findings in this article have been cited by other experts in the relevant medical fields as being necessary to demonstrate a mold allergy. Consequently, when a plaintiff was purportedly unable to support her claims that she sustained various allergic and neurological injuries secondary to mold exposure with these test results confirming her mold allergy, a New York County judge dismissed these claims without allowing them to go before a jury for consideration.
Deadly Sin #2 - Failing to Get Appropriate and Timely Environmental Testing that Confirms the Presence of Injury-Inducing Mold
The scientific literature over the last several years has consistently noted that while exposure to certain fungi, or molds, can cause human illness through allergy or hypersensitivity, direct infection by the organism, or toxic-irritant effects from mold byproducts, not all species of mold have been correlated with these reactions. Therefore, simply showing pictures depicting apparent mold growth are insufficient to prove mold injury; in order for a mold exposure claim to survive, the plaintiff will likely need to show that specific species of molds, which have been scientifically linked to the particular injuries alleged, were present in sufficient amounts to cause these injuries.
Deadly Sin #3 - Failing to Notify The Landlord or Contractor About Potential Mold Problems in The Home
One of the bedrock principles of the United States tort system is that a landowner may not be held liable for a dangerous condition on his property unless the claimant can prove that the owner either knew, or should have known of this defect, and that it existed for a sufficient length of time prior to the incident complained of to permit the owner's employees to discover and remedy it. This is commonly referred to as the "notice" doctrine. In that regard, there are reported cases from New York's appellate courts stating that even where a landlord is tacitly aware of discoloration of walls, and has knowledge of previous water damage from a flood, neither constitutes "notice" of a likelihood of mold growth. Consequently, unless the owner is specifically notified of a mold condition, the claim may be subject to dismissal.
Copyright (c) 2008 Law Offices of Jonathan Cooper
Deadly Sin #1 - Failing to Get Appropriate and Timely Clinical Testing that Confirms a Mold Allergy
A 2006 peer-reviewed article published by the Journal of Allergy and Clinical Immunology recommends that patients with a suspected mold allergy should undergo an accepted skin or blood test for IgE antibodies to mold antigens as part of a clinical evaluation for mold allergies. The findings in this article have been cited by other experts in the relevant medical fields as being necessary to demonstrate a mold allergy. Consequently, when a plaintiff was purportedly unable to support her claims that she sustained various allergic and neurological injuries secondary to mold exposure with these test results confirming her mold allergy, a New York County judge dismissed these claims without allowing them to go before a jury for consideration.
Deadly Sin #2 - Failing to Get Appropriate and Timely Environmental Testing that Confirms the Presence of Injury-Inducing Mold
The scientific literature over the last several years has consistently noted that while exposure to certain fungi, or molds, can cause human illness through allergy or hypersensitivity, direct infection by the organism, or toxic-irritant effects from mold byproducts, not all species of mold have been correlated with these reactions. Therefore, simply showing pictures depicting apparent mold growth are insufficient to prove mold injury; in order for a mold exposure claim to survive, the plaintiff will likely need to show that specific species of molds, which have been scientifically linked to the particular injuries alleged, were present in sufficient amounts to cause these injuries.
Deadly Sin #3 - Failing to Notify The Landlord or Contractor About Potential Mold Problems in The Home
One of the bedrock principles of the United States tort system is that a landowner may not be held liable for a dangerous condition on his property unless the claimant can prove that the owner either knew, or should have known of this defect, and that it existed for a sufficient length of time prior to the incident complained of to permit the owner's employees to discover and remedy it. This is commonly referred to as the "notice" doctrine. In that regard, there are reported cases from New York's appellate courts stating that even where a landlord is tacitly aware of discoloration of walls, and has knowledge of previous water damage from a flood, neither constitutes "notice" of a likelihood of mold growth. Consequently, unless the owner is specifically notified of a mold condition, the claim may be subject to dismissal.
Copyright (c) 2008 Law Offices of Jonathan Cooper
Related Tags: mold testing, mold allergy, mold injury, proving mold case
Jonathan Cooper is an attorney in private practice in New York. He represents small businesses, property owners and individuals in New York's trial and appellate courts. For more information on his firm, please visit www.jmcooperlaw.com Your Article Search Directory : Find in Articles
Recent articles in this category:
- Work Cover Lawyers Help Workers Favored In New Contingency Agreement
Were you ever given a small amount of compensation after having been injured on your job? Have exper - Florida Last Will And Testament Information
A person who is at least 18 years of age can complete a Florida Last Will and Testament and is refer - Florida Durable Power Of Attorney Information
A Florida durable power of attorney is a legal document that designates a person to act on behalf of - California Power Of Attorney Information
In California any adult person who has the ability to enter into an agreement can complete and sign - Criminal Lawyer
Sexual assaults are increasing with alarming frequency and everyday there are news reports about var - Fort Lauderdale Foreclosure Lawyer Explains, Foreclosure Is Not Your Only Option, You Have A Choice
Foreclosure has been one of the foremost topics within the real estate world in recent years, as eac - Should You Make A Personal Injury Claim?
Personal injury claims now gain wider exposure than ever before, yet many people are still unaware o - Mesa Bankruptcy- Regain Financial Stability
Are you drowning in overwhelming debt? Is it causing you mental, emotional and physical distress? Ta - How Bankruptcy Can Help You Financially Start Over With A Clean Slate
Fed up with debt? Desperately want to be free from the unbearable problem? If yes, then you should n - Major Yasmin Birth Control Side Effects
Yasmin is a popular form of hormonal birth control that has been heavily marketed, especially to you
Most viewed articles in this category:
- Be Aware of Single Owner LLC Tax Problems
One of the more popular business entity choices these days is the limited liability company. If - 14 Tips on How Parents Who Have a Child with a Disability Can Organize Their Estate
Copyright © 2007 L. Mark Russell As a general rule, parents should keep their original document - IF OUR PETS WERE REALY OUR "MINOR CHILDREN" MOST OF US "PARENTS" WOULD BE IN JAIL FOR CHILD NEGLECT
As a pet owner, do you need to have a pet trust or will in your estate plan? Well, maybe so, given - The Last Will And Testament - A Model NOT To Live By
The death of Anna Nicole Smith has at least one valuable outcome, even if it is simply serving as a - The British Constitutional Reform Act
The Constitutional Reform Act of 2005 changed the British hitherto unwritten constitution by in - Patented Drugs
While a drug or process is under patent, other companies are wary of working anything even remote - Divorce and Debt
As common sense and statistics tell us, the leading cause of marital discord is money. Therefore - The Misunderstood World of Corporate Minutes
The corporation is the most used form of business entity in the United States. While many people - Attorney for Legal Services
All of us hire lawyers at one point or the other. People get sued, arrested, charged for a crime, - Should Parents EVER Leave an Inheritance Outright to a Child who has a Disability?
Copyright © 2007 L. Mark Russell There are few absolutes in estate planning, but this is one. I